HomeMy WebLinkAboutIR 10514 INFORMAL REPORT TO CITY COUNCIL MEMBERS No. 20-10514
To the Mayor and Members of the City Council November 17, 2020
Page 1 of 1
i
i7 Y
SUBJECT: FINAL COMMENTS ON TRWD GENERAL ORDINANCE AND
rrn COMMERCIAL FACILITIES ORDINANCE
The purpose of this report is to provide the City Council with the attached letter to Tarrant Regional Water District
(TRWD)commenting on proposed revisions to its General Ordinance and Commercial Facilities Ordinance.The
letter is signed by the cities of Fort Worth, Arlington, Mansfield, Euless, North Richland Hills, and Haltom City. The
content is consistent with the comments outlined in the October 20 Informal Report to the City Council.
Staff intends to present the letter to the TRWD board at its regular meeting on Tuesday, November 17, at 9:00 am.
We have encouraged other cities and development stakeholders to speak as well.The letter requests that TRWD
convene a stakeholder group to address the ordinance revisions.
The full TRWD ordinance revisions can be found here:
https://www.trwd.com/resources/board-of-directors/#public-comment
For any questions on this report, please contact Dana Burghdoff, Assistant City Manager, at 817-392-8018.
David Cooke
City Manager
Attachment
ISSUED BY THE CITY MANAGER FORT WORTH, TEXAS
FORTWORTK,
rr
ARL1 NGTON=� �pN�FIE LICE
THE dMEPICAN DREAM CITY L A 7
T1-1 E CITY OF
EULESSI IRH
NORTH KICHT-AND HTTIS /Zj&
HALTOM CITY
November 10, 2020
James Oliver
General Manager
Tarrant Regional Water District
800 E. Northside Drive
Fort Worth, TX 76102
Re: City of Fort Worth, City of Arlington, City of Mansfield, City of Euless, City of North
Richland Hills and City of Haltom City's collective comments regarding the Tarrant
Regional Water District's Proposed Changes to the General Ordinance and Commercial
Facilities Ordinance
Dear Jim,
The City of Fort Worth, City of Arlington, City of Mansfield, City of Euless, City of North Richland
Hills and City of Haltom City have worked collaboratively to address concerns we share in Tarrant
Regional Water District's proposed ordinance. Collectively, we as stakeholders believe the
ordinance is subject to interpretations that are overreaching and the effects of the ordinance
could lead to adverse or conflicting actions within each of our jurisdictions.
The cities recognize Tarrant Regional Water District (TRWD) as an almost 96-year old water
control and improvement district tasked with obtaining and maintaining a safe supply of raw
Tarrant Regional Water District
November 10, 2020
Page 2
water. The TRWD is also charged and authorized to regulate recreational activities on and near
its four freshwater reservoirs. The TRWD is empowered to exercise reasonable authority to
maintain the safe, sanitary and adequate supply of water stored in its reservoirs.
It has been maintained by TRWD that the power it seeks to exert in the proposed ordinance is
reflective of power it already has through its enabling legislation and various statutes. We
believe, however,that the ordinance as currently drafted could lead to conflicts with the specific
authority of the governmental entities. Moreover, the ordinance has the potential to place
impractical burdens on individual property owners regarding routine use and improvement of
their properties. In short order we believe the ordinance:
• Establishes an expanded Service Area for water and property for which there are no
adjudicated rights to regulate and that overlaps other jurisdictional boundaries.
• Is overly broad by asserting that District Land includes all land that drains to District
Water.
• Is overly broad by asserting that District Water includes all bodies or accumulations of
water, natural or artificial, located within the district's Service Area.
• Improperly seeks to regulate water quality.
• Imposes conflicting TRWD development requirements within other governmental
jurisdictions.
• Allows TRWD's General Manager the unilateral right to promulgate, order and impose
development, construction and maintenance standards for land in other governmental
jurisdictions.
• Requires the district's customers to adopt ordinances implementing TRWD's master
drainage plan and other plans for water quality, and preventing waste or unauthorized
use of District Water.
As recognized, TRWD is a water control and improvement district created by the legislature
pursuant to Article XVI, section 59, of the Texas Constitution for "[t]he conservation and
development of all of the natural resources of this State, and development of parks and
recreational facilities, including the control, storing, preservation and distribution of the waters
of its rivers and streams ... ." However, TRWD is governed and limited by its enabling legislation
as well as Chapters 49 and 51 of the Texas Water Code. Under this enabling legislation, TRWD's
purposes are:
(1) to secure and maintain safe, sanitary, and adequate plumbing installations,
connections, and appurtenances as subsidiary parts of sanitary sewer systems;
(2) to preserve the sanitary condition of all land and water controlled by the district;
Tarrant Regional Water District
November 10, 2020
Page 3
(3) to prevent the waste or unauthorized use of water;
(4) to regulate residing, hunting, fishing, boating, and camping, and all recreational and
business privileges on any body or stream of water, or any body of land, or any easement
owned or controlled by the district;
(5) to regulate privileges on any land,easement, or property interest adjoining a reservoir
or other property of the district to prevent activities on such adjoining land, easement, or
property interest that could adversely affect the purity of water in this state; and
(6) to promote state or local economic development and stimulate business and
commercial activity in the district.
TRWD's proposed ordinance seeks to expand this authority by enacting regulations applicable to
land, property and water that the district does not control either by ownership, statute or
adjudicated rights. TRWD has not been given the power to regulate land, property or water it
does not own or control.
Additionally, through this ordinance TRWD seeks to exercise jurisdiction and regulate water
quality standards which are outside of the district's authority. It is the State of Texas that has
such authority. Certainly TRWD's watershed can be protected pursuant to the provisions of the
Texas Water Code; however, the regulatory authority for enforcing these protections belongs
with the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality.
The limitation on the authority of the district was emphasized in 1991 when Governor Ann
Richards vetoed HB 2056 which would have allowed TRWD the right to enter onto private
property to conduct inspections and determine if water quality standards were being met and if
proper permits were obtained for effluent discharge. Governor Richards stated that the bill
attempted to grant TRWD powers that belonged to the State and "would allow the district to
have significant and extraordinary powers outside the district limits, including the right to intrude
upon private lands." Simply put, the proposed ordinance over extends the legislatively enabled
purposes granted to TRWD in 2005.
Tarrant Regional Water District
November 10, 2020
Page 4
We appreciate your willingness to work with the governmental entities that are affected by your
regulations. We propose that a stakeholder group, to include ourselves and others affected by
the proposed ordinance, be formed and convene to better understand the issues and concerns
TRWD is attempting to address and would like to share our thoughts at a meeting for this
purpose. Together, it is likely we can achieve the ultimate goals that TRWD desires to accomplish
through this ordinance.
Respectfully,
Davi ooke TreyYelNager
City Manager, Fort Worth City Maington
47 'OF
Loretta Getche Mark Hindman
City Manager, Euless City Manager, North Richland Hills
r
Rex Phelps
City Manager, Haltom City A
Smolinsk)
Manager,Mansfield