HomeMy WebLinkAboutContract 44465 (2)r. �. w _; ,���.
�� � P•'.f', - - - s � - - -
CITY OF FORT WOR.TH, TEXAS
STANDARD AGREEMENT FOR ENGINEERING RELATED DESIGN SERVICES
This AGREEMENT is between the City of Fort Worth, a Texas home-rule
municipality (the "CITY"), and Rodney R. Thornhill d/b/a White Rock Consultants,
authorized to do business in Texas, (the "ENGINEER"), for a PROJECT generally
described as: Contract Management of Interceptor Condition Assessment Program (ICAP)
2012.
Article I
Scope of Services
A. The Scope of Services is set forth in Attachment A.
Article II
Compensation
I1
The ENGINEER's compensation shall be in the amount of $189,207.00 as
set forth in Attachment B.
Article III
Terms of Payment
Payments to the ENGINEER will be made as follows:
A. Invoice and Payment
(1) The Engineer shall provide the City sufficient documentation, including but
not limited to meeting the requirements set forth in Attachment D to this
AGREEMENT, to reasonably substantiate the invoices.
(2) The ENGINEER will issue monthly invoices for all work performed under this
AGREEMENT. Invoices are due and payable within 30 days of receipt.
(3) Upon completion of services enumerated in Article I, the final payment of
any balance will be due within 30 days of receipt of the final invoice.
(4) In the event of a disputed or contested billing, only that portion so contested
will be withheld from payment, and the undisputed portion will be paid. The
City of Fort Worth, Texas
Standard Agreement for Engineering Related
PMO OKcial Release Date: t/28/2013 �
Page 1 of 16
� ' � ` � T �.
� .i '( � � � ' � -
� 4 �
No interest will
resolved.
accrue on any contested portion of the biliing until mutually
(5) If the CITY fails to make payment in full to ENGINEER for billings contested
in good faith within 60 days of the amount due, the ENGINEER may, after
giving 7 days' �written notice to CITY, suspend services under this
AGREEMENT until paid in full. In the event of suspension of services, the
ENGINEER shall have no liability to CITY for delays or damages caused the
CITY because of such suspension of services.
Article IV
Obligations of the Engineer
Amendments to Article IV, if any, are included in Attachment C.
A.
�
C.
General
The ENGINEER will serve as the CITY's professional engineering
representative under this Agreement, providing professional engineering
consultation and advice and furnishing customary services incidental
thereto.
Standard of Care
The standard of care applicable to the ENGINEER's services will be the
degree of skill and diligence normally employed in the State of Texas by
professional engineers or consultants performing the same or similar
services at the time such services are performed.
Subsurface Investigations
(1) The ENGINEER shall advise the CITY with regard to the necessity for
subcontract work such as special surveys, tests, test borings, or other
subsurface investigations in connection with design and engineering
work to be perFormed hereunder. The ENGINEER shall also advise
fhe CITY concerning the results of same. Such surveys, tests, and
investigations sh�ll be furnished by the CITY, unless athenrvise
specified in Attachment A.
(2) In soils, foundation, groundwater, and other subsurface investigations,
the actual characteristics may vary significantly between successive
test points and sample intervals and at locations other than where
City of Fort Worth, Texas
Standard Agreement for Engineering Related Design Services
PMO O�cial Release Date: 1J28/2013
Page 2 of 16
observations, exploration, and investigations have been made.
Because of the inherent uncertainties in subsurface evaluations,
changed or unanticipated underground conditions may occur that
could affect the total PROJECT cost and/or execution. These
conditions and cost/execution effects are not the responsibility of the
ENGINEER.
D. Preparation of Engineering Drawings
The ENGINEER will provide to the CITY the original drawings of all plans in
ink on reproducible mylar sheets and electronic files in .pdf format, or as
otherwise approved by CITY, which shall become the property of the CITY.
CITY may use such drawings in any manner it desires; provided, however,
that the ENGINEER shall not be liable for the use of such drawings for any
project other than the PROJECT described herein.
E. Engineer's Personnel at Construction Site
(1) The presence or duties of the ENGINEER's personnel at a construction site,
whether as on-site representatives or otherwise, do not make the
ENGINEER or its personnel in any way responsible for those duties that
belong to the CITY and/or the CITY's construction contractors or other
entities, and do not relieve the construction contractors or any other entity of
their obligations, duties, and responsibilities, including, but not limited to, all
construction methods, means, techniques, sequences, and procedures
necessary for coordinating and completing all portions of the construction
work in accordance with the Contract Documents and any health or safety
precautions required by such construction work. The ENGINEER and its
personnel have no authority to exercise any control over any construction
contractor or other entity or their employees in connection with their work or
any health or safety precautions.
(2) Except to the e�ent of specific site visits expressly detailed and set forth in
Attachment A, the ENGINEER or its personnel shall have no obligation or
responsibility to visit the construction site to become familiar with the
progress or quality af the completed work on the PROJECT or to determine,
in general, if fihe wark on the PF20JECT is being performed in a manner
indicating �hat the PROJECT, when completed, will be in accardance with
the Contract Documents, nor shall anything in the Contract Dacuments or
the �greement between CITY and E�IGINEER be construed as requiring
ENGINEER to make exhaustive or continuous on-site inspections to
discover latent defects in the work or otherwise check the quality or quantity
of the work on the PROJECT. If the ENGINEER makes on-site
observation(s) of a deviation from the Contract Documents, the ENGINEER
City of Fort Worth, Texas
Standard Agreement for Engineering Related Design Services
PMO Official Release Date: 1/28/2013
Page 3 of 16
shall inform the CITY.
(3) When professional certification of performance or characteristics of
materials, systems or equipment is reasonably required to perform the
services set forth in the Scope of Services, the ENGINEER shall be entitled
to rely upon such certification to establish materials, systems or equipment
and performance criteria to be required in the Contract Documents.
F. Opinions of Probable Cost, Financial Considerations, and Schedules
(1) The ENGINEER shall provide opinions of probable costs based on the
current available information at the time of preparation, in accordance
with Attachment A.
(2) In providing opinions of cost, financial analyses, economic feasibility
projections, and schedules for the PROJECT, the ENGINEER has no
control over cost or price of labor and materials; unknown or latent
conditions of existing equipment or structures that may affect operation
or maintenance costs; competitive bidding procedures and market
conditions; time or quality of performance by third parties; quality, type,
management, or direction of operating personnel; and other economic
and operational factors that may materially affect the ultimate
PROJECT cost or schedule. Therefore, the ENGINEER makes no
warranty that the CITY's actual PROJECT costs, financial aspects,
economic feasibility, or schedules will not vary from the ENGINEER's
opinions, analyses, projections, or estimates.
G. Construction Progress Payments
Recommendations by the ENGINEER to the CITY for periodic construction
progress payments to the construction contractor will be based on the
ENGINEER's knowledge, information, and belief from selective sampling
and observation that the work has progressed to the point indicated. Such
recommendations do not represent that continuous or detailed examinations
have been made by the ENGINEER to ascertain that the construction
contractor has completed the work in exact accordance with the Contract
Documents; that the final work will be acceptable in all respects; that the
ENGINEER has made �n examination to ascertain how or for what purpose
the constructian contractor has used the moneys paid; that title to any of the
wark, materials, or equipment has passed to the CITY free �nd clear of liens,
claims, security interests, or encumbrances; or that there are nat other
matters at issue between the CITY and the construction contractor fhat
affect the amount that should be paid.
H. Ftecord Drawings
City of Fort Worth, Texas
Standard Agreement for Engineering Retated Design Services
PMO Official Release Date: 1/28/2013
Page 4 of 16
Record drawings, if required, will be prepared, in part, on the basis of
information compiled and furnished by others, and may not always represent
the exact location, type of various components, or exact manner in which the
PROJECT was finally constructed. The ENGINEER is nat responsible for
any errors or omissions in the information from others that is incorporated
into the record drawings.
I. Minority Business and Small Business Enterprise (MBE)(SBE)
Participation
In accord with the City of Fort Worth Business Diversity Ordinance No.
20020-12-2011, as amended, the City has goals for the participation of
minority business enterprises and/or small business enterprises in City
contracts. Engineer acknowledges the MBE and SBE goals established for
this contract and its accepted written commitment to MBE and SBE
participation. Any misrepresentation of facts (other than a negligent
misrepresentation) and/or the commission of fraud by the Engineer may
result in the termination of this Agreement and debarment from participating
in City contracts for a period of time of not less than three (3) years.
J. Right to Audit
(1) ENGINEER agrees that the CITY shall, until the expiration of five (5) years
after final payment under this contract, have access to and the right to
examine and photocopy any directly pertinent books, documents, papers
and records of the ENGINEER involving transactions relating to this
contract. ENGINEER agrees that the CITY shall have access during normal
working hours to all necessary ENGINEER facilities and shall be provided
adequate and appropriate work space in order to conduct audits in
compliance with the provisions of this section. The CITY shall give
ENGINEER reasonable advance notice of intended audits.
(2) ENGINEER further agrees to include in all its subconsultant agreements
hereunder a provision to the effect that the subconsultant agrees that the
CITY shall, until the expiration of five (5) years after final payment under the
subcontract, have access to and the right to examine and photocopy any
directly pertinent baoks, documents, papers �nd recnrds nf such
subcansultant, involving transactians to the subcontract, and further, that the
CITY shall have access during normal working hours to all �ubcc�nsultant
facilities, and shall be provided adequate and appropriate
order to conduct audits in compliance with the provision
together with subsection (3) hereof. CITY shall give
reasonable advance notice of intended audits.
work space, in
s of this article
subconsultant
City of Fort Worth, Texas
Standard Agreement for Engineering Related Design Services
PMO Official Release Date: 1/28/2013
Page 5 of 16
(3) ENGINEER and subconsultant agree to photocopy such documents as may
be requested by the CITY. The CITY agrees to reimburse ENGINEER for
the cost of copies at the rate published in the Texas Administrative Code in
effect as of the time copying is performed.
K. INSURANCE
(1) ENGINEER'S INSURANCE
a. Commercial General Liability — the ENGINEER shall maintain
commercial general liability (CGL) and, if necessary, commercial
umbrella insurance with a limit of not less than $1,000,000.00 per each
occurrence with a$2,000,000.00 aggregate. If such Commercial General
Liability insurance contains a general aggregate limit, it shall apply
separately to this PROJECT or location.
i. The CITY shall be included as an insured under the CGL, using
ISO additional insured endorsement or a substitute providing
equivalent coverage, and under the commercial umbrella, if any.
This insurance shall apply as primary insurance with respect to
any other insurance or self-insurance programs afforded to the
CITY. The Commercial General Liability insurance policy shall
have no exclusions by endorsements that would alter or nullify:
premises/operations, products/completed operations, contractual,
personal injury, or advertizing injury, which are normally contained
within the policy, unless the CITY approves such exclusions in
writing.
ii. ENGINEER waives all rights against the CITY and its agents,
officers, directors and employees for recovery of damages to the
extent these damages are covered by the commercial general
liability or commercial umbrella liability insurance maintained in
accordance with this agreement.
b. Business Auto — the ENGINEER shall maintain business auto liability
and, if necessary, commercial umbrella liability insurance with a limit af
nat less than $1,000,004 each accident. Such insurance shall cover
liability arising out of "any auto", including owned, hired, and non-�wned
autos, when said vehicle is used in the caurse of the PROJECT. If the
engineer owns no vehicles, coverage for hired or non-owned is
acceptable.
i. ENGINEER waives all rights against the CITY and its agents,
officers, directors and employees for recovery of damages to the
City oF Fort Worth, Texas
Standard Agreement for Engineering Related Design Services
PMO O�cial Release Date: 1l28/2013
Page 6 of 16
extent these damages are covered by the business auto liability or
commercial umbrella liability insurance obtained by ENGINEER
pursuant to this agreement or under any applicable auto physical
damage coverage.
c. Workers' Compensation —ENGINEER shall maintain workers
compensation and employers liability insurance and, if necessary,
commercial umbrella liability insurance with a limit of not less than
$100,000.00 each accident for bodily injury by accident or $100,000.00
each employee for bodily injury by disease, with $500,000.00 policy limit.
ENGINEER waives all rights against the CITY and its agents,
officers, directors and employees for recovery of damages to the
extent these damages are covered by workers compensation and
employer's liability or commercial umbrella insurance obtained by
ENGINEER pursuant to this agreement.
i2)
d. Professional Liability — the ENGINEER shall maintain professional
liability, a claims-made policy, with a minimum of $1,000,000.00 per
claim and aggregate. The policy shall contain a retroactive date prior to
the date of the contract or the first date of services to be performed,
whichever is earlier. Coverage shall be maintained for a period of 5 years
following the completion of the contract. An annual certificate of
insurance specifically referencing this project shall be submitted to the
CITY for each year following completion of the contract.
GENERAL INSURANCE REQUIREMENTS
a. Certificates of insurance evidencing that the ENGINEER has obtained all
required insurance shall be delivered to the CITY prior to ENGINEER
proceeding with the PROJECT.
b. Applicable policies shall be endorsed to name the CITY an Additional
Insured thereon, as its interests may appear. The term CITY shall
include its employees, officers, officials, agents, and volunteers as
respects the contracted seniices.
c. Gertificate(s) of insurance sh�ll document that insur�nce coverage
specified in this agreement �re provided under applicable policies
documented thereon.
d. Any failure on part af the CITY to request required insurance
documentation shall not constitute a waiver of the insurance
requirements.
City of Fort Worth, Texas
Standard Agreement for Engineering Related Design Services
PMO Official Release Date: 1/28/2013
Page 7 of 16
e. A minimum of thirly (30) days notice of cancellation or material change in
coverage shall be provided to the CITY. A ten (10) days notice shall be
acceptable in the event of non-payment of premium. Notice shall be sent
to the respective Department Director (by name), City of Fort Worth,
1000 Throckmorton, Fort Worth, Texas 76102.
f. Insurers for all policies must be authorized to do business in the State of
Texas and have a minimum rating of A:V or greater, in the current A.M.
Best Key Rating Guide or have reasonably equivalent financial strength
and solvency to the satisfaction of Risk Management.
g. Any deductible or self insured retention in excess of $25,000.00 that
would change or alter the requirements herein is subject to approval by
the CITY in writing, if coverage is not provided on a first-dollar basis. The
CITY, at it sole discretion, may consent to alternative coverage
maintained through insurance pools or risk retention groups. Dedicated
financial resources or letters of credit may also be acceptable to the
C ITY.
h. Applicable policies shall each be endorsed with a waiver of subrogation
in favor of the CITY as respects the PROJECT.
i. The CITY shall be entitled, upon its request and without incurring
expense, to review the ENGINEER's insurance policies including
endorsements thereto and, at the CITY's discretion; the ENGINEER may
be required to provide proof of insurance premium payments.
j. Lines of coverage,
claims-made basis,
prior to the date
insurance shall stat
claims-made.
other
shall
of the
e both
than Professional Liability, underwritten on
contain a retroactive date coincident with
contractual agreement. The certificate
the retroactive date and that the coverage
.�
or
of
is
k. Coverages, whether written on an occurrence or claims-made basis,
shall be maintained without interruption nor restrictive modification or
changes from date of commencement of the PROJECT until final
payment and termination of any coverage required to be maintained after
final payments.
fihe CITY shall not be responsible for the direct payment r�f any
insurance premiums required by this agreement.
m. Sub consultants and subcontractors to/of the ENGINEER shall be
required by the ENGINEER to maintain the same or reasonably
equivalent insurance coverage as required for the ENGINEER. When
City of Fort Worth, Texas
Standard Agreement for Engineering Related Design Services
PMO O�cial Release Date: 1/28/2013
Page 8 of 16
sub consultants/subcantractors
ENGINEER shali provide CITY
certificate of insurance.
L.
M.
N.
O.
�
maintain insurance coverage,
with documentation thereof on a
Independent Consultant
The ENGINEER agrees to perform all services as an independent
consultant and not as a subcontractor, agent, or employee of the CITY.
Disclosure
The ENGINEER acknowledges to the CITY that it has made full disclosure
in writing of any existing conflicts of interest or potential conflicts of interest,
including personal financial interest, direct or indirect, in property abutting the
proposed PROJECT and business relationships with abutting property cities.
The ENGINEER further acknowledges that it will make disclosure in writing
of any conflicts of interest that develop subsequent to the signing of this
contract and prior to final payment under the contract.
Asbestos or Hazardous Substances
(1) If asbestos or hazardous substances in any form are encountered or
suspected, the ENGINEER will stop its own work in the affected portions
of the PROJECT to permit testing and evaluation.
(2) If asbestos or other hazardous substances are suspected, the CITY may
request the ENGINEER to assist in obtaining the services of a qualified
subcontractor to manage the remediation activities of the PROJECT.
Permitting Authorities - Design Changes
If permitting authorities require design changes so as to comply with
published design criteria and/or current engineering practice standards
which the ENGINEER should have been aware of at the time this
Agreement was executed, the ENGINEER shall revise plans and
specifications, as required, at its own cost and expense. However, if design
changes are required due to the changes in the permitting authorities'
published de�ign �riteria and/or practice standards criteria which are
published after the date af this Agr�ement which the ENGINEER ceuld not
have been reasanably aware c�f, the ENGINEER shall notify the CITY of
such changes and an adjustment in compensation will be made through an
amendment to this AGREEMENT.
�
City of Fort Worth, Texas
Standard Agreement for Engineering Related Design Services
PMO O�cial Release Date: 1/28/2013
Page 9 of 16
ENGINEER shall manage the PROJECT in accordance with the schedule
developed per Attachment D to this AGREEMENT.
Article V
Obligations of the City
Amendments to Article V, if any, are included in Attachment C.
A.
�
C.
�
C�
City-Furnished Data
ENGINEER may rely upon the accuracy, timeliness, and completeness of
the information provided by the CITY.
Access to Facilities and Property
The CITY will make its facilities accessible to the ENGINEER as required for
the ENGINEER's performance of its services. The CITY will perform, at no
cost to the ENGINEER, such tests of equipment, machinery, pipelines, and
other components of the CITY's facilities as may be required in connection
with the ENGINEER's services. The CITY will be responsible for all acts of
the CITY's personnel.
Advertisements, Permits, and Access
of-way, and
construction.
Unless otherwise agreed to in the Scope of Services, the CITY will obtain,
arrange, and pay for all advertisements for bids; permits and licenses
required by local, state, or federal authorities; and land, easements, rights-
access necessary for the ENGINEER's services or PROJECT
Timely Review
The CITY will examine the ENGINEER's studies, reports, sketches,
drawings, specifications, proposals, and other documents; obtain advice of
an attorney, insurance c�unselor, accountant, auditor, bond and financial
advisors, and other consultants �s the CITY deems appropriate; and render
in writing decisions required by the CITY in a timely manner in accordance
with the project schedule prepared in accordance with Attachment D.
Prampt Notice
The CITY will give prompt written notice to the ENGINEER whenever CITY
City of Fort Worth, Texas
Standard Agreement for Engineering Related Design Services
PMO O�cial Release Date: 1/28/2013
Page 10 of 16
F.
G.
H.
observes or becomes aware of any development that affects
timing of the ENGINEER's services or of any defect in the
ENGINEER or construction contractors.
Asbestos or Hazardous Substances Release.
the scope or
work of the
(1) CITY acknowledges ENGINEER will perform part of the work at CITY's
facilities that may contain hazardous materials, including asbestos
containing materials, or conditions, and that ENGINEER had no prior
role in the generation, treatment, storage, or disposition of such
materials. In consideration of the associated risks that may give rise to
claims by third parties or employees of City, City hereby releases
ENGINEER from any damage or liability related to the presence of
such materials.
(2) The release required above shall not apply in the event the discharge,
release or escape of hazardous substances, contaminants, or asbestos
is a result of ENGINEER's negligence or if ENGINEER brings such
hazardous substance, contaminant or asbestos onto the project.
Contractor Indemnification and Claims
The CITY agrees to include in all construction contracts the provisions of
Article IV.E. regarding the ENGINEER's Personnel at Construction Site, and
provisions providing contractor indemnification of the CITY and the
ENGINEER for contractor's negligence.
Contractor Claims and Third-Party Beneficiaries
(1) The CITY agrees to include the following clause in all
construction contractors and equipment or materials suppliers:
contracts with
"Contractors, subcontractors and equipment and materials
suppliers on the PROJECT, or their sureties, shall maintain
no direct action against the ENGINEER, its o�cers,
employees, and subcontractors, for any claim arising out of,
in connection with, or resulting from the engineering
services perFormed. Only the CITY will be the beneficiary
of any undertaking by the ENGINEER."
(2) This AGREEMENT giv�s no rights or benefits to anyone other than the CITY
and the ENGINEER and there are no third-party beneficiaries.
(3) The CITY will include in each agreement it enters into with any other entity
or person regarding the PROJECT a provision that such entity or person
shall have no third-party beneficiary rights under this Agreement.
City of Fort Worth, Texas
Standard Agreement for Engineering Related Design Services
PMO O�cial Release Date: 1/28/2013
Page 11 of 16
(4) Nothing contained in this section V.H. shall be construed as a waiver of any
right the CITY has to bring a claim against ENGINEER.
I. CITY's Insurance
(1) The CITY may maintain property insurance on certain pre-existing structures
associated with the PROJECT.
(2) The CITY will ensure that Builders Risk/Installation insura
at the replacement cost value of the PROJECT. The (
ENGINEER a copy of the policy or documentation of such
insurance.
�ce is maintained
ITY may provide
on a certificate of
(3) The CITY will specify that the Builders Risk/Installation insurance shall be
comprehensive in coverage appropriate to the PROJECT risks.
J.
K.
Litigation Assistance
The Scope of Services does not include costs of the ENGINEER for required
or requested assistance to support, prepare, document, bring, defend, or
assist in litigation undertaken or defended by the CITY. In the event CITY
requests such services of the ENGINEER, this AGREEMENT shall be
amended or a separate agreement will be negotiated between the parties.
Changes
The CITY may make or approve changes within the general Scope of
Services in this AGREEMENT. If such changes affect the ENGINEER's cost
of or time required for performance of the services, an equitable adjustment
will be made through an amendment to this AGREEMENT with appropriate
CITY approval.
Article VI
. . . -r: ` • •
Amendments to Article VI, if any, ar� included in Attachment C.
. . �- � � . � .�
ENGINEER shall be authorized to proceed with this AGREEMENT upon
receipt of a written Notice to Proceed from the CITY.
City of Fort Worth, Texas
Standard Agreement for Engineering Related Design Services
PMO Official Release Date: 1/28/2013
Page 12 of 16
B. Reuse of Project Documents
All designs, drawings, specifications, documents, and other work products of
the ENGINEER, whether in hard copy or in electronic form, are instruments
of service for this PROJECT, whether the PROJECT is completed or not.
Reuse, change, or alteration by the CITY or by others acting through or on
behalf of the CITY of any such instruments of service without the written
permission of the ENGINEER will be at the CITY's sole risk. The CITY shall
own the final designs, drawings, specifications and documents.
C. Force Majeure
The ENGINEER is not responsible for damages or delay in performance
caused by acts of God, strikes, lockouts, accidents, or other events beyond
the control of the ENGINEER that prevent ENGINEER's performance of its
obligations hereunder.
D. Termination
(1) This AGREEMENT may be terminated only by the City for convenience on
30 days' written notice. This AGREEMENT may be terminated by either the
CITY or the ENGINEER for cause if either party fails substantially to perform
through no fault of the other and does not commence correction of such
nonperFormance with in 5 days of written notice and diligently complete the
correction thereafter.
(2) If this AGREEMENT is terminated for the convenience of the City, the
ENGINEER will be paid for termination expenses as follows:
a.) Cost of reproduction of partial or complete studies, plans,
specifications or other forms of ENGINEER'S work product;
b.) Out-of-pocket expenses for purchasing electronic data files and other
data storage supplies or services;
c.) The time rsquirements for the ENGINEER'S personnel to document
the work underway at the time of the CITY`S termination for
convenience so that the work effort is suitable for long time storage.
(3) Prior to proceeding with termination services, the ENGINEER will
submit to the CITY an itemized statement of all termination expenses. ihe
CITY'S approval will be obtained in writing prior to proceeding with
termination services.
City of Fort Worth, Texas
Standard Agreement for Engineering Related Design Services
PMO O�cial Release Date: 1/28l2013
Page 13 of 16
E. Suspension, Delay, or Interruption to Work
The CITY may suspend, delay, or interrupt the services of the ENG(NEER
for the convenience of the CITY. in the event of such suspension, delay, or
interruption, an equitable adjustment in the PROJECT's schedule,
commitment and cost of the ENGINEER's personnel and subcontractors,
and ENGINEER's compensation will be made.
F. Indemnification
In accordance with Texas Local Government Code Section 271.904, the
ENGINEER shall indemnify, hold harmless, and defend the CITY
against liability for any damage caused by or resulting from an act of
negligence, intentional tort, intellectual property infringement, or
failure to pay a subcontractor or supplier committed by the ENGINEER
or ENGINEER's agent, consultant under contract, or another entity
over which the ENGINEER exercises control.
G. Assignment
Neither party shall assign all or any part of this AGREEMENT without the
prior written consent of the other party.
H. Interpretation
Limitations on liability and indemnities in this AGREEMENT are business
understandings between the parties and shall apply to all the different
theories of recovery, including breach of contract or warranty, tort including
negligence, strict or statutory liability, or any other cause of action, except for
willful misconduct or gross negligence for limitations of liability and sole
negligence for indemnification. Parties mean the CITY and the ENGINEER,
and their officers, employees, agents, and subcontractors.
I. Jurisdiction
The law of the State of Texas shall govern the validity of this AGREEMENT,
its interpretation and perFormance, and any other claims related to it. The
venue for �ny litigatian related to this AGREEMENT shall be Tarrant County,
Texas.
City of Fort Worth, Texas
Standard Agreement for Engineering Related Design Services
PMO Official Release Date: 1/28/2013
Page 14 of 16
J
K.
Severability and Survival
If any of the provisions contained in this AGREEMENT are held for any
reason to be invalid, illegal, or unenforceable in any respect, such invalidity,
illegality, or unenforceability will not affect any other provision, and this
AGREEMENT shall be construed as if such invalid, illegal, or unenforceable
provision had never been contained herein. Articles V.F., VI.B., VI.D., VI.F.,
VI.H., and VI.I. shall survive termination of this AGREEMENT for any cause.
Observe and Comply
ENGINEER shall at all times observe and comply with all federal and State
laws and regulations and with all City ordinances and regulations which in
any way affect this AGREEMENT and the work hereunder, and shall
observe and comply with all orders, laws ordinances and regulations which
may exist or may be enacted later by governing bodies having jurisdiction or
authority for such enactment. No plea of misunderstanding or ignorance
thereof shall be considered. ENGINEER agrees to defend, indemnify and
hold harmless CITY and all of its officers, agents and employees from and
against all claims or liability arising out of the violation of any such order, law,
ordinance, or regulation, whether it be by itself or its employees.
Article VII
Attachments, Schedules, and Signatures
This AGREEMENT, including its attachments and schedules, constitutes the entire
AGREEMENT, supersedes all prior written or oral understandings, and may only be
changed by a written amendment executed by both parties. The following attachments
and schedules are hereby made a part of this AGREEMENT:
Attachment A- Scope of Services
Attachment B — Compensation
Attachment C- Amendments to Standard Agreement for Engineering Services
Attachment D - Project Schedule
Attachment E - Location Map
City of Fort Worth, Texas
Standard Agreement for Engineering Related Design Services
PMO O�cial Release Date: 1/28I2013
Page 15 of 16
Executed and effective this the
BY:
CITY OF FORT WORTH
BY:
ENGINEER
Rodney R. Thornhill d/b/a
White Rock Consultants�
�� day of ���, �i �� , 2013.
�
. .,
Fernando Costa
Assistant City Manager
Date: S Z2 /3
APPROV,
By:.�
RECOMMENDED:
f r��
S. Frank Crumb, P.E.
Director, Water Department
APPROVED AS TO FORM AND
LEGALITY
Rod Thornhill
President
Date:
�oll 3
M&C: C-26228
M&C Date:
gy. �� L�,u �i� � 11 (( ,.�:,� �
Douglas W. Black � � � � i< � � �
, ��t�,<
Assistant City Attorney
0
,/
- 1 �( - ?-,� � ; -
Mar�/J. Kayser
City Secretary
City of Fort Worth, Texas
Standard Agreement for Engineering Related Design Services
PMO OFficial Release Date: 1/28/2013
Page 16 of 16
M
7. 2013
t� ,
. '% '. 1
r
; � :�
.�.v��"'_ �' �� •,
ATTACHMENT A
��(��� IPSn
C�� � . �
CONTRACT MANAGEMENT OF INTERCEPTOR CONDITION ASSESSMENT
PROGRAM (ICAP)
ICAP Scope of Work Descriation
The City of Fort Worth selected White
Freese and Nichols to provide engineering
and Contract 2.
Rock Consuitants and sub-consultant
services and manage ICAP Contract 1
Deliverables of the project include the following and they are described in details
elsewhere in this document;
• Develop a work plan and tracking procedures for the ICAP
• Provide monthly status reports and monitor ICAP progress
� Provide Engineering reports for ICAP work orders
• Prepare executive briefing on ICAP program status and findings
• Integrate findings and recommendations into the current Wastewater
Master Plan now underway by Freese and Nichols and including any
modifications to Cap Plan
Document procedures and methodologies for use in long term interceptor
assessment and planning.
1.0
1.1
ICAP PROGRAM IMPLEMENTATION AND MANAGEMENT
Project Management of ICAP
A. Perform general administration duties during the project, including
progress monitoring, scheduling, general correspondence, office
administration, and invoicing.
B. Conduct quarterly progress meetings on ICAP with Field Operations and
Engineering to review progress, discuss data needs, benefits of ICAP
and any topics of special concern. The project team will develop the
presentation for each of the quarterly meetings. The results of these
meeting will be provided in the Monthly Status Report.
C. Monthly Status Report will b� submitted, summarizing progress against
specific tasks and scheduled tasks to be accomplished in the upcoming
mon#h; outlining upcoming key decisions which will require input from, or
discussion with, City staff; �nd listing any problems or unresolved
issues.
Attachment A
City of Fort Worth, Texas
Standard Agreement (or Engineering Services
PMO Official Release Date: 05/04/2012
Page 1 of 5
1.2 Implementation of ICAP Work Pian
A. Prioritize and review work orders including initial quantities, project limits
and special procedures necessary including exhibits identifying
beginning and ending stations and project location.
B. Conduct attribute data review of each sewer line segment identified in
each work order to determine initial pipe wall thickness and other critical
data needed for ICAP geodatabase.
The project team will research the following data sources: GIS, As-
Builts, As-Design, Pipe Manufacturer, project files, vault records, FVWVD
engineering old water construction files, etc.
C. Populate wall thickness data, location of reinforced steel and hydraulic
modeling results for each of the pipeline segments in each ICAP work
order to ICAP geodatabase.
D. Confirm that Contractor has completed an Initial Review of CCTV and
Sonar Inspection to determine quality of inspections and completeness
of inspections.
E. Update ICAP geodatabase to track each work order assignment
including project status, quantities performed for inspection and cleaning
activities performed conditions, and data corrections.
F. Conduct full engineering analysis of CCTV, sonar, and laser profiling
inspection data including interpretation of laser profile results to
determine completeness of inspections and to assess structural
condition of pipeline segment.
G. Correct defect coding where necessary using software specified by
FW1ND and communicate to contractor any recurring errors that crews
are making.
H. Based on review of sonar data, initiate any required pipeline cleaning
work orders inctuding quantities and project limits, with exhibits under
cleaning contract. Review post cleaning sonar inspection for adequacy
and issue work order for inspection as necessary.
Review pay requests from contractor by comparing actual work
approved to work invoiced and recommend either payment to the
contractor or follow-up work by contractor to camplete the work.
J. Use inspection results and physical data on sewer interceptors to
develop remaining useful life (RUL) estimates for each pipeline
segment. Populate ICAP geodatabase with identified RUL score for
each pipeline segment. Create a map book that graphically displays an
RUL score for each of the pipeline segment.
K. Scan and hyperlink shop drawing data to sewer line assets within ICAP
geodatabase.
Attachment A
City of Fort Worth, Texas
Standard Agreement for Engineering Services
PMO Official Release Date: 05l04/2012
Page 2 of 5
L. Prepare Draft Engineering Report with CIP recommendations for areas
of rehabilitation and identify overall condition for each pipe segment
The report will also include CCTV, sonar
required areas of cleaning, payment
information, any defects requiring immediat
RUL estimates.
���
and laser profiling results,
quantities, geodatabase
e repairs and assignment of
M. Meet with City to review Draft Engineering Report findings and present
recommendations (up to 3 meetings).
N. Finalize Engineering Report after receiving comments from City Staff.
INCORPORATION OF WASTEWATER CIP INTO ICAP
RECOMENDATIONS
Upon request, the ENGINEER will provide additional engineering services that are
not described in the Tasks above. For any such work, ENGINEER will first furnish
a written scope, fee estimate, and revised schedule that the CITY will approve in
writing before the ENGINEER may proceed with the work.
A. Develop master planning level cost estimates for
replacement for capital improvement projects for pipe
RUL score of 4 or 5.The project team will incorporate
the ICAP report.
rehabilitation
segments with
cost estimates
or
a
in
B. Incorporate Wastewater Master Plan Capital Improvements into ICAP
recommendations for pipe segments with a RUL score of 4 or 5.
C. Provide FWWD with a memorandum that flags areas that require
hydraulic modeling refinements. These areas will include discrepancies
between hydraulic modeling results (dry weather) and ICAP field
inspections (HDTV, sonar and laser data).
Life of contract
It is contemplated that work will be issued to the EGINEER for work to be
performed under this Contract for not to exceed 365 calendar days following the
date of the Notice to Proceed or expenditure of $189,207 whichever should occur
first. If the cost of the work performed under this Contract is less than $189,207 at
the end of the 365 calendar day period, at the City's option and the ENGINEER's
concurrence, the Project may be extended to $189,207maximum price.
Option to renew
The City has the right to renew this coniract for THREE (3) one year
termslexpenditures under the same terms, conditions, and unit prices. The City
shall give the Contractor at least sixty (60) days notice prior to the expiration of
one year from the date of the Notice to Proceed if it chooses to execute the
option to renew.
Attachment A
City of Fort Worth, Texas
Standard Agreement for Engineering Services
PMO Official Release Date: 05/04/2012
Page 3 of 5
Proiect Team Roles
The prime firm is White Rock Consultants and the sub-consultant is Freese and
Nichois.
The Contractor awarded the project is Ace Pipeline Cleaning, Inc., for ICAP
Contract 1 and Contract 2.
RESPONSIBILITIES OF CITY: CITY shall perform the following in a timely
manner so as not to delay the services of Engineer:
A. Designate in writing a person to act as CITY's representative with respect to
the services to be rendered under this AGREEMENT. Such person shall
have contract authority to transmit instructions, receive information,
interpret and define CITY's policies and decisions with respect to
Engineer's services for the Project.
B. The CITY will provide its GIS integration code to assign unique identifier
numbers to asset-based data.
C. Provide all criteria and full information as to CITY's requirements for the
Project, including design objectives and constraints, space, capacity and
performance requirements, flexibility and expandability, and any budgetary
limitations; and furnish copies of all design and construction standards
which CITY will require to be included in the drawings and specifications.
D. Assist Engineer by placing at ENGINEER's disposal all available
information pertinent to the Project including previous reports and any other
data relative to design or construction of the Project.
E. Assist ENGINEER regarding access to and provisions for ENGINEER to
enter upon public and private property as required for ENGINEER to
perform services under this AGREEMENT.
F. Examine all studies, reports, sketches, drawings, specifications, proposals
and other documents presented by ENGINEER, obtain advice of an
attorney, insurance counselor and other consultants as CITY deems
appropriate for such examination and render in writing decisions pertaining
thereto within a reasonable time so as not to delay the services of
ENGINEER.
G. Furnish approvals and permits from a(! governmental �uthorities having
jurisdiction �ver the Project �nd such approvals and �onsents from athers
as may be necessary for completion of the Project.
H. Provide such accounting, independent cost estimating and insurance
counseling services as may be required for the Project, such legal services
as CITY may require or ENGINEER may reasonably request with regard to
Attachment A
City of Fort Worth, Texas
Standard Agreement for Engineering Services
PMO Official Refease Date: 05/04l2012
Page 4 of 5
legal issues pertaining to the Project including any that may be raised by
Contractor(s), such auditing service as CITY may require to ascertain how
or for what purpose any Contractor has used the moneys paid under the
construction contract, and such inspection services as CITY may require to
ascertain that Contractor(s) are complying with any law, rule, regulation,
ordinance, code or order applicable to their furnishing and performing the
work.
CITY will have the opportunity to review all contractor submittals prior to
ENGINEER's approvals. CITY shall make prompt reviews.
J. Give prompt written notice to
otherwise becomes aware of a
timing of ENGINEER's services,
work of any Contractor.
K. Furnish, or direct ENGINEER
in Attachment A, Article 1
required.
L
M
ENGINEER whenever CITY observes or
ny development that affects the scope or
or any defect or nonconformance of the
to provide, Additional Services as stipulated
of this AGREEMENT or other services as
Provide easement acquisition.
Provide all archeological services required for the project.
N. Provide notifications to all environmental permitting authorities and
negotiations for environmental permit applications.
END OF SECTION
Attachment A
City of Fort Worth, Texas
Standard Agreement for Engineering Services
PMO Official Release Date: 05/04/2012
Page 5 of 5
ATTACHMENT B
COMPENSATION
A. Basic Services: Compensation to ENGINEER for the Basic Services in Attachment A shall
be at a cost plus with a maximum fee of $189,207 as set forth in Exhibit B-1.
If ENGINEER sees the Scope of Services changing so that additional seroices are needed,
including but not limited to those services described as Additional Services in Attachment A,
ENGINEER will notify CITY for CITY's approval before proceeding. Additional Services
shall be computed based on the Schedule of Charges.
Direct Expenses Actual Cost Times Multiplier of 1.05
Other direct expenses shall include outside printing and reproduction expense,
communication expense, travel, transportation and subsistence away from Fort Worth and
other miscellaneous expenses directly related to the work, including costs of laboratory
analysis and testing. Other work required to be done by independent consultants other than
staff members will be billed at cost times a multiplier of 1.10. For CAD services performed
In-house by non-ENGINEER employees where ENGINEER provides workspace and
equipment to pertorm such services, these services will be billed at cost times a multiplier of
2.0. This markup approximates the cost to ENGINEER if an ENGINEER employee was
performing the same or similar services.
Rates for In-house Services
Comauter
$10.00 per hour
Printinq
Black and White
$0.10 per copy
Plotter
Bond
Special
$ 2.50 per plot
$ 5.00 per plot
Color
$0.50 per copy
c . �
$5.75 per book
Attachment B
City of Fort Worth, Texas
Standard Agreement for Engineering Services
PMO OfTicial Release Date: OSl04/2012
Page 1 of 1
� EYHIIIIT B-1
. Schedule of Costs
CONTKAC'T MANAGLNIENT OF INTERCEPTOR CONDITION ASSESSMENT PROGRAM (ICAP) 2012
Task ��NTRACT MANAG�MEIYT OF IIVTEI2CEPTOR CONDTTI�N Project Assist�nt ProJect Project Word Totat �stimuted
AS3ESS141E1vT FROGRAM {iCAi�! Manager Mans�ger Engineer �Is Processor Hours Tota1 Fee
l.l ProjectManagemenYofICAP� � �
Perform geneial ndmirustmtion duties during the project, including progrese
A ino�utoring, echedulvig, general cornespondence, office adminiatration, and 42 4 24 A 74 $11,617
invoicuig.
Conduct quartedy progress meetinga on ICAP wiUt Field Operatione and
Engineeiing to revie�v progresa, discusa daffi needa, benefits ofICAP and any
B topica ofspecial concern. The project team will develop the presentation for 48 S 36 8 2 102 $16,28'7
each of the quarterly meetings. 1'he results of these meeting will be provided
in the Monthiy Status Report.
Monthly Status Report will be submitted, siunmarizing progress against
C apecific tasks and scheduled taeke to be accomplished in the upcoming month; IZ 2 g 22 $3,614
outlining upcoming key deciaions which will require input &om, or diacussion
with, City staff; and listing any pmblems or waesolved issues.
1.2 Implementation of ICAP Work Plan
Prioritize and review work orders including initial quantitiea, project limits
A and epecial procedures itecessary i�iclud'utg exhibits identifying begitttting and 2 16 12 4 34 $4,813
ending slntions and project location.
Conduct attribute data reviery of each sewer line segment identified in each
B �vork order to determine initial pipe wall thicknese and other critical data 4 125 32 4 16S $26,230
needed for ICAPgeodatabase.
Populate wall thickness data, location of reinforced steel and hydraulic
C modeling results for each of the pipeline segnents in each ICAP work otdet to 2 48 16 2 68 $10,679
ICAP geaiatabase.
Confirm thaY Contractnr has completed an Inifial Review of CCI'V and Sonar
D Inspection to detarmine quality of'v�spections and completeness of 12 12 $1,800
inspections.
Upcla6e ICAP geodatabase to track each work order asaigrunent incluciing
E project shatus, quantitiea perfonned for inspection and cleaning activifies 4 2 8 ld $2,414
perfonned conditions, and data corrections.
Conduct full engineering annlysis ofCCI'V, sonar, and laserprofiling
F inspection data including interpretaaon of laser profile reaul� to determine ZZp 220 �33,000
completeness ofinspections and to assess struchaal condition ofpipeline
segment.
G Correct defect coding where necessary using sofhvare specified by FWWD
32 32 $4,800
nnd communicsite tn contrnctDr any recurririg errors thnt crews are making.
Based on review of sonar data, initiate any required pipeline cleaning work
H orders including quantities and pmject limi�, with e�ibits under cleaning 30 30 $4,500
conhact. Review post cleaning sonar inepection for adequacy and ieaue work
order for utspection as necessazy.
Review pay requeats from crnihactor by compxring actual work approved to
I work invoiced and remmmend either payment to the conhactot or follo�v-up 18 18 $2,700
work by conhactor to complete the work.
Use u�spection reRults arid physical data on yewer intercepto�s to develop
remaining usafiil life (FLUL) estimat� for each pipeline segment Populate
J ICAP ge�ciaffibase �vith identified RUL score for each pipeline segment 18 I 40 t6 74 �11,392
Cre�te n roap buok that giaplucally displays :m RUI, score for each ofUie
pipeline segment.
K Scan and hyperlink shop ctrawi�ig data to sewex line assefs within ICAP 1 10 S 52 �8,646
geodalabase.
Pregare Draft Engineeivig Report with CIP recommendations for areas of
rehabilitation and idenrify overall condition For each pipe segmenk T}te report
L will also include CGTV, sonaz and luser profiling results, required arees of 33 8 24 4 69 �l 1,207
cleaning, payment quantitiea, geodatnbaae infonnelion, eny defects requinng
�immediate re�irs and asaignment o£RUL eetimates.
----- — -- -- ----- - --t— — -- ---
Attachment B-1
City of Fort Worth, Texas
Standard Agreement tor Engineering Services
PUIG v^Yiciai Ralease Gai�: "u5iO4i2092
r�ge 1 bf =
�
N
� EYHIF3IT B-1 ������
Schedule of Costs
CONTRACT i�1ANAGEI�IENT OF INTERCEPTOR CONDITION ASSESS1b1ENT PROGRt1vi (ICAP) 2012
Meet wiUi City to review Draft Engineeruig Report flndings �id present
reconvnendatioi�s (up to 3 meerings). 16 12 8 q 40
F'in�ilize �v�gineering Report for eaclt ICAP work arder wit}un two weeks uf�er
mceiving co�nmertts from City Stnff. 6 `� 2� 30
I.ubor Cost Snbtotul 493 38 AO] 100 24 1,056
Subcousidts�ut �xpenses
(3eneral Expenaes $5�
PmthnA & Plothn¢ _ _
C3enernl E�cpertse
Priiiting & Plotti
penscs Subtotal
1
2 0 1NCURYORATION OF WASTEWATER CIP INTO lCAP
RECOMMENDATIONS
Develop master planning level cost estimates for rehabilitation or replacement
A for capital improvement projects for pipe segments tvith a RUL acore of 4 or
S.The project team will incorporate cost estimates in the ICAP repork
B Incorporate Wastervater Master Plan Capital Improvements into ICAP
recommendations for pipe segmettts with a RUL score of 4 or 5.
Provide N'WWD with a metnorandum that flage areas that require hydraulic
c modeling refinements. These azeas will include discrepancies between
hyclraulic modeling resiilts (dry weather) and ICAP field inspections (HDTV,
sonar and laser data).
Labor Cost Subtotal
Subcousidtank Expenses
General E�enses
Pruttin� & Plattine
General Expense
penses Subtotal
?ORATION OF
ATER
C]
�
�
�
16
32
24
16 8
��
`,�/1
,•��
$5,747
$5,200
�164.64�
�
�� 44 $7,601
28 $4,972
2 30
6 102
$500
$2,500
$400
$4,787
'E�rl
Attachme�t B-1
City of Fort Worth, Texas
Standard Agreement for Engineering Services
PM(] (lt(ini�� Ro�Aase �ate; 05/Q4l20?2
FadG � ui 2
ATTACHMENT C
CHANGED AND AMENDMENTS TO STANDARD AGREEMENT FOR ENGINEERING
SERVICES
NONE
Attachment C
City of Fort Worth, Texas
Standard Agreement for Engineering Services
PMO Official Release Date: 05/Od/2012
Page 1 ot 1
ATTACHMENT D
PROJECT SCHEDULE
ENGINEER is authorized to commence work on the Project upon execution of this
AGREEMENT and agrees to complete the seniices as defined in Attachment A and shall be
dictated by work flow and/or as work pertormed and submitted as defined in the contract
specifications associated ICAP Contract 1 and Contract 2.
CITY review of milestone review submittals will be no longer than three weeks. CITY review of
minor submittals will be no longer than two weeks. Additional time may be granted to
ENGINEER if review times are exceeded.
If ENGINEER's services are delayed through no fault of ENGINEER, ENGINEER shall be
entitled to adjust the contract schedule consistent with the number of days of delay. These
delays may include but are not limited to delays in CITY or regulatory reviews, delays on the
flow of information to be provided to ENGINEER, governmental approvals, etc. These delays
may result in an adjustment to compensation as outlined on the face of this AGREEMENT and
in Attachment B.
Attachment D
City of Fort Worth, Texas
Standard Agreement for Engineering Services
PMO Official Release Date: 05/04/2012
Page 1 of 1
M&C Review
� � ! ,
Page 1 of 2
Official site of the City of Fort Worth, %xas
Fo�_�ri.�
COUNCIL ACTION: Approved on 5/7/2013
DATE:
CODE:
SUBJECT:
5/7/2013 REFERENCE NO.: **G26228 LOG NAME: 601CAP12-WRC
C TYPE: CONSENT PUBLIC HEARING: NO
Authorize Execution of an Engineering Agreement with Rodney R. Thornhill d/b/a White
Rock Consultants in the Amount of $189,207.00 for Contract Management of the
interceptor Condition Assessment Program 2012 (ALL COUNCIL DISTRICTS)
RECOMMENDATION:
It is recommended that the City Council authorize the execution of an engineering Agreement with
Rodney R. Thornhill d/b/a White Rock Consultants in the amount of $189,207.00 for the management
of a Citywide sanitary sewer Interceptor Condition Assessment Program (ICAP) 2012.
DISCUSSION:
On April 30, 2007, the City submitted its Sanitary Sewer Overflow Corrective Action Plan to the Texas
Commission on Environmental Quality (TCEQ). The plan provided for preventive maintenance
cleaning and condition assessment of large diameter sanitary sewer mains, known as the Interceptor
Condition Assessment Prograrn (ICAP).
This citywide proactive program, currently being overseen by Water Department Field Ops, has goals
of identifying and eliminating potential operation and maintenance issues and pipe structural failures
before they occur. Within the Fort Worth wastewater collection system, there are approximately 263
miles of large diameter pipes that are equal to or greater than 24-inch diameter. It is anticipated that
a seven-year program will be required to complete the assessment of all large diameter interceptors.
White Rock Consultants was originally selected pursuant to a Request for Qualifications (RFQ). The
City has independent contracts with at least one entity to perform work under this program. The
engineering services to be performed by White Rock Consultants consist of managing the City's
contractor's activities and developing work plans, procedures, methodologies and criteria to assess
the pipe condition. The engineer will integrate his findings and assessment results with the
Wastewater Master Plan capacity recommendation into a multi-year capital improvements plan.
M/WBE Office: A waiver of the goal for MBE/SBE subcontracting requirements was requested by the
Department and approved by the M/WBE O�ce, in accordance with the M/WBE or BDE Ordinance,
because the purchase of goods or services from source(s) where subcontracting or supplier
opportunities exist are negligible.
This Agreement may be renewed at the City's option three additional times.
This project affects ALL COUNCIL D15iRICTS.
: �- . � - . �
The Financial Mlanagement Services Director certifies that funds are available in the current operating
budget, as appropriated, of the Water and Sewer Fund.
TO Fund/Account/Centers
FROM Fund/AccountlCenters
PE45 539120 0707001 $189,207.00
http://apps.cfwnet.org/council packet/mc review.asp?ID=18249&councildat... 5/8/2013
M&C Review
Submitted for City Manager's Office by:
Originating Department Head:
Additional Information Contact:
ATTACHMENTS
Fernando Costa (6122)
S. Frank Crumb (8207)
Roberto Sauceda (2387)
Page 2 of 2
http://apps.cfwnet.org/council_packet/mc_review.asp?ID=18249&councildat...
5/8/2013