HomeMy WebLinkAbout4. HRC Assessment.Race and Culture StrategiesHuman Relations Commission
Assessment of Race and Culture Strategies
Kimberly Porter, Chair
Human Relations Commission
May 18, 2021
Human Relations Commissioners
2
Rachael Capua Carmen Castro*David Colon Jim DeLong Felipe GutierrezStaussaErvin
Kimberly Porter*Ravi Siripurapu Amanda Stallings Dante Williams Michael Wyss*
* Re-appointed Commissioners
Purpose of HRC
The Fort Worth Human Relations Commission (FWHRC),established in
1967,is made up of citizens appointed by the Fort Worth City Council and
works to promote improved community relations and to eliminate
prejudice and discrimination.
3
ADVISE RECOMMEND PROMOTE
Task Force on Race and Culture
4
The Task Force on Race and Culture was created, via Resolution No. 4817-08-2017, in August 2017 and was assigned three
tasks:
•Community conversations about race and culture
•Assessment of disparities in provision of municipal services
•Leadership Training
In its assessment of disparities, attributable to Race and Culture, the Task Force identified the following areas impacting
Fort Worth resident’s quality of life:
•Criminal Justice
•Economic Development
•Education
•Governance
•Health
•Housing
•Transportation
The Task Force presented its final recommendations to City Council on December 4, 2018, and City Council approved
acceptance of the recommendations on December 11, 2018.
Task Force on Race and Culture
Updates to City Council
•August 2019
•January 2020
•June 2020
•December 2020
5
December 2020 Report Summary
•Criminal Justice, Governance, and Transportation have met or exceeded five-year
disparity measures.
•Education has seen no change in disparity measures.
•Economic Development, Health and Housing have no new data to report due to
reporting source timeline, policy changes, or delays due to COVID, but work is still
underway.
•Several areas reported action strategies not directly tied to five-year disparity measures
or require longitudinal monitoring (more than five years) to measure disparity gaps.
•Staff changes and COVID-19 have impacted progress.
•Changes in policy for governmental organization demographic reporting has significantly
impacted ability to measure progress on disparity measures.
December 2020 Report Next Steps
Human Relations Commission will…
•Review Race and Culture Task Force final report and quarterly progress reports on
implementation.
•Engage community for feedback.
•Partner with City University of New York (CUNY) consultant for the Municipal Equity Plan.
•Work with Diversity and Inclusion Department to provide a formal report to City Manager,
Mayor and Council on recommendations for possible areas of focus changes, stronger
alignment of disparity measures with action strategies, changes in department or city partner
organization responsibilities to achieve and sustain progress.
Eliminating Racial and Cultural Disparities
8
Monitor
progress
Assess
strategies
and actions
Recommend
necessary
changes
Secure
City Council
approval
Human Relations Commission
Task Force on Race and Culture (2017-2018)
Extent of disparities Causes of disparities Recommended strategies
and actions
Success
measures
Attributes of Process to Eliminate Disparities
•Driven by data
•Focused on outcomes
•Informed by public participation
•Linked to community partnerships
9
Task Force on Race & Culture -22 Recommendations
10
Topic Strategy #1 Strategy #2 Strategy #3 Strategy #4
Criminal Justice
Independent oversight
of Police Department
Police cadet program Diversity within
Police Department
Economic
Development
Job training, transportation to
jobs, background issues, and
hiring process
Education and incentives
to achieve wage parity
Capacity-building for
minority-owned businesses
Education
Early childhood intervention
via quality childcare
Service learning and
civic engagement
College and career centers
Governance
Redistricting criteria and
procedures
Diversity and Inclusion Diversity training
Health
Health education and outreach Active lifestyles Healthy foods Access to providers
Housing
Affordable housing incentives
policy
Homebuyer assistance Resident awareness
of housing resources
Transportation
Transportation equity policy
and five-year action plan
Transportation funding criteria After-action reviews of
pedestrian and bicycle
crashes
= 1 or more metric met = 1 or more metric addressed = no metric addressed or met
HRC Review and Update of Recommendations
•How much progress have we made in completing the
recommended actions and thereby implementing the
recommended strategies?
•If necessary,how should we accelerate our progress?
•How effective have these strategies and actions been in
reducing racial and cultural disparities?
•If necessary,how should we adjust our strategies and
actions to achieve better results?
Potential challenges
Responsible parties
Resources needed
•How should we update our five-year objectives?
•How should we engage community leaders and other
residents in meaningful discussions about these issues?
Proposed HRC Report Format
•Disparity: What existing racial/ethnic disparity are we seeking to
reduce or eliminate?
•Strategy: In a sentence, what is our strategy for reducing or
eliminating this disparity?
•Inputs: What resources have we allocated toward implementing the
strategy, e.g. funds, staff time, etc.
•Outputs: What results have we produced in implementing the
strategy?
•Outcomes: To what extent have we reduced the disparity?
12
Committees of Human Relations Commission
to Review Progress on Race and Culture Task Force Recommendations
Committee
HRC Members
City Staff Subject Matter
Expert
Proposed
HRC
Presentation
Date
Chair Member Member
Criminal Justice Carmen Castro Felipe Gutierrez Staussa Ervin Neil Noakes Alex Del Carmen
Tarleton State July 2021
Economic
Development Dante Williams Kimberly Porter Amanda Stallings Robert Sturns Stacy Marshall
Southeast Fort Worth, Inc.April 2021
Education Rachael Capua David Colon Amanda Stallings Lawrence Thompson Kent Scribner
Fort Worth ISD August 2021
Governance Dante Williams Felipe Gutierrez Rachael Capua Fernando Costa September 2021
Health Staussa Ervin Kimberly Porter Ravi Siri Elmer DePaula
Veerinder Taneja
Tarrant County Public
Health
March 2021
Housing Felipe Gutierrez David Colon Jim Delong Victor Turner
Amy Connolly
Mary Margaret Lemons
Fort Worth Housing
Solutions
May 2021
Transportation Mike Wyss Carmen Castro Staussa Ervin William Johnson
Chad Edwards
Chad Edwards
Tarrant Transit Alliance June 2021
Presentation Completed
•May –September 2021: HRC committees to continue meeting and
reviewing recommendations.
•October -November 2021: Finalize HRC report to City Council.
Next Steps
Thank you