Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout(0075) ZC-21-131Date: February 8, 2022 Case Number: ZC-21-131 Zoning Map Amendment Case Manager: Sarah Bergman Owner /Applicant: Site Location: Proposed Use: Request: Mmarooful H. Choudhury / Peter Kavanaugh 8661 & 8689 John T. White Road Request Townhomes Council District: 5 Acreage: 5.10 acres From: "B" Neighborhood Commercial and "A-5" One -Family To: "PD/R2" Planned Development for all uses in "R2" Cluster/Townhome excluding two-family dwellings (attached or detached), industrialized housing, school (elementary or secondary), government office facility, neighborhood recreation center, and gas drilling and production and with development standards attached in Exhibit A and with specific development standards for to open space; site plan included Land Use Compatibility: Comprehensive Plan Consistency: Staff Recommendation: Zoning Commission Recommendation: 1. Proiect Description and Background Recommendation Requested change is compatible. Requested change is not consistent. Denial Denial with Prejudice by a vote of 7-2 Table of Contents 2. Surrounding Zoning and Land Uses 3. Recent Zoning HistorX 4. Public Notification 5. Development Impact Analysis a. Land Use Compatibility b. Comprehensive Plan Consistency c. Site Plan Comments 6. Exhibit A — Development Standards 7. Area Zoning Map with 300 ft. Notification Area 8. Site Plan 9. Area Map 10. Future Land Use Map 11. Aerial Photograph Project Description and Background The site is located at the northeast corner of John T. White Road and Randol Mill Road/Eastchase Parkway. It is located just over one-third mile north of Interstate 30. The site is currently zoned "E" Neighborhood Commercial and the applicant is requesting to rezone to "PD/R2" Planned Development for all uses in "R2" Townhouse/Cluster, excluding two-family dwellings (attached or detached), industrialized housing, school (elementary or secondary), government office facility, neighborhood recreation center, and gas drilling and production. The applicant is also proposing specific development standards that are attached as "Exhibit A." A very small portion along the eastern side of the property is zoned "A-5" One -Family, but this area is not large enough for development as currently zoned. This request was originally considered by the Zoning Commission on September 8, 2021 as a request for standard "R2" zoning. At that meeting, the applicant requested a 60-day continuance to allow for additional time to meet with neighborhood groups. At the November 10, 2021 hearing, the applicant indicated that they would be revising the request to PD zoning and a second 60-day continuance was granted to allow for proper noticing and submission of the PD site plan. The attached site plan depicts 40 new lots intended for attached townhome development with six total buildings. The applicant is imposing a height limitation of two -stories for the two buildings along the eastern side of the property, and three -stories for all other buildings. Each unit is proposed to have a rear -access, two -car enclosed garage as well as two surface parking spaces, all located behind the front build wall. Common areas are shown along the John T. White Boulevard and Randol Mill Road frontages as well as in the eastern corner of the property. The site plan also depicts dedication of a new public street with connections on John T. While Boulevard and Randol Mill Road. Transportation and platting staff have identified concerns with the proposed street and alley layout which are described in the "Site Plan Comments" section of this staff report. However, these items will need to be evaluated separately as the Zoning Commission is unable to waive requirements of the subdivision ordinance or access management policy. The table below described the differences in development requirements for standard "R2" Townhouse/Cluster zoning, and the standards proposed with this PD: 11 i Requirement "R2" Standards Maximum 24 units/acre Proposed "PWR2" Standards 70 Density Complies (7.7 units/acre provided) Height Maximum height 36' Complies Front Yard: None required Front Yard: 10-ft Rear Yard: None required Rear Yard: 25-ft Required Yards Interior Side Yard: 5' minimum Interior Side Yard: 5-ft Corner Lot Side Yard: 10 Corner Lot Side Yard: 10-ft minimum adjacent to both streets Complies Maximum 250 feet maximum Complies (maximum provided 225-ft) Facade Length Building Separation 10 feet minimum Complies Open space as shown on the site plan is not compliant with zoning ordinance requirements as it is not accessible to the residents. A masonry wall is shown separating these areas from the townhome sites. The Open Space 15% minimum applicant is requesting a development standard in order to include these areas in open space calculations. This request is not supported by staff. Development Standard Required Two spaces per dwelling unit, Minimum located behind the front building lineexcept for limited , Parking analysis not provided on site plan. Applicant Parking local streets or private access has indicated that four parking spaces will be provided Requirements easements, where four spaces per unit. No waivers are requested. shall be required Surrounding Zoning and Land Uses North: "A-5" One -Family / single-family dwellings; and "E" Neighborhood Commercial / undeveloped directly adjacent; mosque and school further north East: "A-5" One -family / single-family dwellings South: "E" Neighborhood Commercial / undeveloped; and "PD66" / residential West: "PD626" / retail; and "PD578" / multifamily Recent Zoning History • ZC-20-047 from "PD169" Planned Development/Specific Use for E Neighborhood Commercial plus ice skating rink, site plan required to multiple tracts "A-7.5" One -Family (5.95 acres) / "R2" Townhouse/Cluster (3.09 acres) / "E" Neighborhood Commercial (2.95 acres); west of subject site; effective 7/16/20 • ZC-19-156 City initiated rezoning for over 700 acres; lots north and northwest of subject site; effective 12/28/19 Public Notification 300-foot Legal Notifications were mailed on December 30, 2021. The following organizations were notified: (emailed December 28, 2021) Or anizations Notified Historic Randol's Mill Valley Alliance, Inc. Neighborhoods of East Fort Worth John T White NA of East Fort Worth Bentley Villa e-Waterchase NA* East Fort Worth, Inc. Streams and Valleys Inc Trinity Habitat for Humanity East Fort Worth Business Association Fort Worth ISD * Located within this registered neighborhood organization Development Impact Analysis Land Use Compatibility The applicant is requesting to rezone from "E" Neighborhood Commercial to "PD/R2" Planned Development for all uses in "R2" Townhouse/Cluster with exclusions and development standards. The surrounding land uses include single family residential, multifamily residential, undeveloped, and retail. The proposed zoning is compatible with surrounding land uses. Comprehensive Plan Consistency — Eastside The 2021 Comprehensive Plan currently designates the subject property as "Neighborhood Commercial" on the Future Land Use Map. The excerpt below from the Comprehensive Plan indicates that multifamily residential is considered appropriate within the Neighborhood Commercial designation, but single-family development such as townhomes on individually platted lots is not. Neighborhood Commercial Retail, services, offices and mixed uses serving daily needs for a local Multifamily Residential, ER, market area E, MU-1 General Commercial Retail, services, offices and mixed uses serving occasional needs for a Multifamily Residential, ER, larger market area E, MU-1, MU-2 Mixed -Use/ Retail, services, offices, entertainment, mixed uses, and multifamily AR, B, R1, R2, CR, C, D, UR, Mixed -Use Growth Center residerilial; Cvuionunily Growlli Centers are less inlerrsive, anal Regional all Coninrercial, MU-1, MU-2, Growth Centers are more intensive corm -based Codes The proposed zoning is not consistent with the land use designations for this area, and does not align with the following policies of the Comprehensive Plan: Locate large commercial and institutional uses adjacent to arterial streets, preferably at the intersections of other arterials and highways. Use appropriate incentives to promote development of vacant land and redevelopment or reuse of deteriorated properties within designated commercial districts. Additionally, City of Fort Worth officials have expressed concern that the City is losing commercial corridors to residential development and that this trend should not be continued. This site is located at a hard corner of two arterial roadways, is surrounded by other commercially zoned and used land, and is designated as Neighborhood Commercial in the Comprehensive Plan. Based on lack of conformance with the policies stated above, the proposed zoning is not consistent with the Comprehensive Plan. Site Plan Comments Zoning and Land Use - Please add the following to the site plan: o A date and signature line for "Director of Development Services" in the lower righthand corner, as well as the zoning case number (ZC-21-131). o Zoning of surrounding properties ("A-5" One -Family for residential lots to the north and east, "E" Neighborhood Commercial for subject property and site to the north) o The legal description for this site. o The following general notes: ■ This project will comply with Section 6.301, Landscaping. ■ This project will comply with Section 6.302, Urban Forestry. ■ All signage will conform to Article 4, Signs. ■ All provided lighting will conform to the Lighting Code. - Please label the following: o Height and material of the existing fencing at the eastern edge of the property. o Pavement type for driveways and internal alleys. o Proposed site density (units per acre). - The location and dimension of all proposed structures should be depicted on the site plan. Please indicate where the townhome buildings and associated parking areas will be located and label total square footage and building height. - A parking analysis is required. The minimum parking requirement is two spaces per dwelling unit, located behind the front build wall. Please label minimum required and total provided spaces. - The proposed open space areas do not appear to meet the intent of the Zoning Ordinance as they are separated from the residential properties by masonry walls. Please indicate how these areas will be utilized by the residents of this development. A waiver will be required for the current design. - FYI — an encroachment agreement may be needed for the portions of the masonry wall that are proposed within the utility easements along the property boundaries. Platting - Provide information on the proposed townhomes. If sold as individual fee simple lots, a preliminary plat is required. Subdivision Ordinance, Section 31-106(g) Alley design standards. (1) Length. Alleys shall be of a similar length as their associated opposite and parallel primary service streets, except for any additional length required for turnout returns to the primary service street. Dead- end alleys are prohibited. An alley with only one outlet shall be provided with an approved turn -around. The proposed multifamily development is proposed over two separate platted lots (Bentley Village Addition, Block MR, Lot 2, Lot 3). A final short plat (replat) is recommended to avoid any potential conflict with provisions of the Subdivision Ordinance standards ( i.e. utilities crossing over property lines, access management drive way spacing. Transportation - Access to all proposed lots is subject to the Fort Worth Access Management Policy. A waiver to the access management policy is required for the proposed access onto John T. White and Randol Mill road. - Single-family and two-family residential alley width is 16ft. with 12 ft. paving edge to edge. Deadened alleys require a waiver from the planning commission. - On Commercial Connector right-of-way driveway spacing is 250 feet and 200 feet on Neighborhood connectors. Fort Worth Fire Department - Failure to recognize violations of the fire code by the fire code official does not waive the requirement of meeting minimum requirements of the fire code in the future. - It is the applicant's and the owner's responsibility to meet all minimum fire code requirements at all times. - The City of Fort Worth has adopted the 2015 International Fire Code as its current fire code at the time of this review. The City of Fort Worth also has adopted amendments (January 1, 2017 version) to this code. The Fort Worth Fire Code Amendments can be found online at www.fortworthtexas.gov/Fire/ (click on Bureau of Fire Prevention) (Comments made by Platting (Subdivision Ordinance), Transportation/Public Works, Fire, Park & Recreation, and Water Department staff cannot be waived through the Zoning Commission and City Council. Approval of the zoning site plan does not constitute the acceptance of conditions.) "Exhibit A" Development within the proposed "PD/R2" District shall be in conformance with the Zoning Ordinance requirements for "R2" Townhouse/Cluster, except as noted for the development standards provided below: 1. The development must conform to the attached site plan. 2. The two structures on the easternmost side of the site plan are limited to two (2) stories in height. 3. All other structures are limited to three (3) stories in height. 4. All individual town homes must have a two -car enclosed garage. 5. All garages must face alleys shown on the site plan. 6. No lot will have a front entrance garage. 7. The maximum number of town homes permitted on this site is 40. 8. Exteriors of homes will be stone or brick, except for openings, window -sills, garage doors, roof facias and exposed exhaust vents. 9. A masonry wall will be built on all sides of the property adjacent to alleys and along property lines separating the residential lots and the lots in Bentley Village Section 3 Subdivision and along John T. White Boulevard and Randol Mill Road. 10. An open wrought iron -type fence, six feet in height, will be erected along the north property line adjacent to Lot 1, Block M of Bentley Village Addition (Church Property). An open wrought iron -type fence, six feet in height, will be erected along John T. White Boulevard beginning at the wall on the east side of the easternmost 20' alley at its intersection with the masonry wall and running to the point that is the intersection of the John T. White right of Way with the westernmost point of lot 3, Block F of Bentley Village, Section 3 Addition. 11. Front yard setbacks must be a minimum of ten (10) feet. 12. Rear yard setbacks must be a minimum of twenty-five (25) feet. 13. Streets and alleys shown on the site plan must be built to City of Fort Worth street and alley standards. 14. Development must conform to the attached site plan with only exceptions caused by City of Fort Worth public streets, alleys or required public easements and corner visibility standards. 15. The areas depicted as open space in the attached site plan will be counted towards the minimum 15% requirement for "R2" zoning. FORTWORTH® Area Zoning Map Applicant: MMarooful Choudhury Address: 8661 & 8689 John T. White Road Zoning From: A-5, E Zoning To: PD for R2 uses Acres: 5.10269796 Mapsco: 67U Sector/District: Eastside Commission Date: 1/12/2022 Contact: 817-392-2806 ZC-21-131 } — 50 7007007007007M700N 621 8701 i4? �, {. � ,$a 808 700700700700700700? Bug 700700700070070]T ,.p r4 740 740 700 325 J `� ��' Y � 820 �� �; 700 7700703 328 a $iT �sf ' g24 a3]il 5 {ga 812 ° 43j f ° Z29 E s,�, as ,y� _�-y fir a 800 d? am 825 raj Y" m a75 arf a2D 309 w05 6 803 a NO 17 S12 817 4 ,r� 9EA el' E \N KRISTA LU M1 kYM1 o PD30s1s _ q.CL LU 8700 8700 �. 8772 8758 _ ,tl,.i w 7QF o 1201 M;51 asa7 PD353 E -, 1,01 � { Subject Area `+}° ass, ® 300 Foot Notification D 1134 PD 1, ._„ 0 190 380 760 Feet Created: 12/ 17/2021 8: 50:0 8 A M I I PROPOSED 6' MASONRY SCREENI G FENCE I RA .=1385.36: LE .=300.47' _ DEL TAB 12'25'36 "- CH. BEAR.=N8'08'04"W CH. LE=299.88' PROPOSED I6' MASONRY - SCREENING FENCE Q J I J_ r I J 0 O O� Z Q� /QM 04 O PROPOSED ' MASONRY SCREENING FENCE N46020'11 "-14.22' I LOT 1, BLOCK M BENTLEY VILLAGE ADDITION \ CAB. B, SLIDE 1614 PRTCT PROPOSED 6' WROUGHT IRON FENCE 1 N88 °34'31 "E- 402.77' 20' ALLEY 7' 33.92' I25' 1X � 30.00, FLz,- 25.00' 25.00' BUILDING 25.00' LINE 30.00, 30.00, 25,00' 25' 25.00' BUILDING 25.00' LINE 25.00' 25.00' 1 J 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 4,788 lSF o 1 0 I 0 U o 0 000 SF 0 0 0 2, 500 SF 0 0 0 2, 500 SF 0 0 0 ?, 500 SF 0 0 0 3, 000 SF 0 0 0 3, 000 SF 0 0 0 2, 500 SF 0 0 0 2, 500 SF 0 0 0 2, 500 SF 0 0 0 ?, 500 SF 0 0 0 2, 500 SF 0 2, 923 SF o p o J 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 I I m 30.84' 10' BUILDING LINE 10' BUILDING LINE 25.00" 30.00' 25.00' 30.00" 25.00' 25.00' 30.00' 25.00' 25.00' 25.00' 25.00' 7.5' UTILITY EASEMENT 120' TEXAS MIDSTREAM GAS PIPELINE EASEMENT - �E7F A 50' RIGHT-OF-WAY PROPOSED 6' MASONRY SCREENING FENCE BLOCK F BENTLEY VILLAGE, SECTION 3 VOL. 388-97, PG. 19 PRTCT 14.17' 14X 289.97' "PROPOSED 6' MASONRY SCREENING FENCE - EE7F A 50' RIGHT-OF-WAY LOT 8 N88 °19'02 "E- 25.571 30.00' 25.00' 25.00' 25.00" 20.00' A 1� 20.00' 25.00' 25.00' 25.00' 25.00' 25.00' 25.00' 30.00' 30.00' 25.00' 25.00' 25.00' 25.00' 25.00' 25.00' 25.00'\\ 10' BUILDING LINE 10' BUILDING LINE 10' BUILDING LINE R w z w z w z w z w z w z I J I J J J J J r 1 X 0 2 3 4 5 6 0 0 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 . 14 . 15 0 016 17 18 19 20 21 22 c� 23 0 Q 114, 351 SF J O bbb E5000 SF o O O O J p 2, 500 SF o 2, 500 SF o 2, 500 SF o 2, 900 SFJ w J O � 900 SF o O 2, 500 SF o O O O O O O 2, 500 SF o 2, 500 SF o 2, 500 SF o 2, 500 SF o 2, 500 SF o 2, 500 SF o J O 3, 000 ' j o J O 3-�00 SF o O O 2, 500 SF o 2, 500 SF o O 2, 500 SF o O O O 2, 500 SF o 2, 500 SF a 2, 500 SF o 3, 450 SF m o m o 0 0 o m J m o 0 0 0 0 0 0 o m o m o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 � 25' BUILDING LINE Q 25' BUILDING LINE 25' BUILDING LINE -I o I 23.64' 30.00' ,�k 25.00' 25.00' 25.00' 20.00' A A 20.00' 25.00' 25.00' 25.00' 25.00' 25.00' 25.00' 30.00' 30.00' 25.00' 25.00' 25.00' 25.00' 25.00' 25.00' 35.00' 20' ALLEY PROPOSED 6' MASONRY SCREENING FENCE 2O' ALLEY PROPOSED 6' MASONRY SCREENING FENCE o oo' N N N - 1X-- 7.5' UTILITY EASEMENT 359.01' S88 °32'59 "W- 359.01 JOHN T. WHITE BOULEVARD 120' RIGHT-OF-WAY F Ri I,eR WEST a EWPORT P� GQ� U a< O s1-4 JIMMIE BULL = Z SARTAIW 0 JOHN T WHITE ARKHILL w a SITE a ��� U �+� COTTONWOOD of Li ANDERSON VILLAGE o Q � Creek TWIN Q 6.8 DALLA U OAKW00 Q 0 0 EDERVILLE Z < SS m 0 YOr G�P�� Harrison NP��RpR 0 Yo G Cern a m B ENTWO D STAIR o pp m m 0 Q w a PN pP LOCATION MAP N.T.S. - - 7.5' UTILITY EASEMENT 254.50' S88 °20'36 "W-506. SITE DA TA TOTAL SITE AREA - 225, 963 SQ. FT. OR 5.1874 ACRES NET SITE AREA = 56, 254 SF OR 1.2914 ACRES TOTAL NUMBER OF RESIDENTIAL LOTS - 40 REQUIRED PROVIDED OPEN SPACE 15% (33, 894 SF) 47, 087 SF = 20. 8% UN/ TS PER ACRE 24 MAX. 7.7 MAXIMUM FACADE LENGTH 250 FT. 225 FT. FRONT YARD 0 FT 10 FT SIDE YARD 5 FT 5 FT SIDE YARD ADJ. TO STREET 10 FT 10 FT REAR YARD 0 FT 25 FT HEIGHT 35 FT MAX. 35 FT. MAX. BUILDING SEPARATION 10 FT. MIN. 10 FT. MIN. LEGEND 1� : LOT 7 LOT 6 PROPOSED 6' MASONRY SCREENING FENCE �'l7 5' BUILD11N5G LINE—] R. 0 2, 900 SF o N 100.00' N N Z Z500 SF w z N J 100.00" J z z 17 z o o � 2,500 SF 0 o O N � � N m 100.00' m o 18 �' N o 0 2,500 SF o N N 1010900' Z,500 SF N N 120.00' 5' 3, 000� SF BUILDING LINE 100, 00' R 0U.41 7.5' UTILITY EASEMENT J O PROPOSED 6' MASONRY SCREENING FENCE JOHN T. WHITE BOULEVARD 120' RIGHT-OF-WAY � Q \\ O LOT 5 w s U Z O w 2 w z �2 Z -� W 763 w 92 Of U U) Z o DETENTION POND a zw Ld 1 4X w 0- 26,534 SF rz O 62.69' 7.5' UTILITY EASEMENT 0 0 z Q PROPOSED OPEN SPACE PROPOSED 6' WROUGHT IRON FENCE PROPOSED 6' MASONRY SCREENING FENCE OWNER: MmAR00FUL H. CHOUDHURY 13151 EMILY ROAD DALLAS, TEXAS 75240 TEL. 214-335-3428 email: Tauhid@tasacom.com 11 40' 80' 120' GRAPHIC SCALE LOT 4 BLOCK F BENTLEY VILLAGE, SECTION 3 VOL. 388-97, PG. 19 PRTCT LOT 3, BLOCK F ' BENTLEY VILLAGE, SECTION 3 n� VOL. 388-97, PG. 19 PRTCT NNE V REVISIONS: PREPARED BY: RENGINEERS & CONSULTANTS, INC. TSBPE REGISTRATION NUMBER F-8527 ENGINEERS • SURVEYORS • LAND PLANNERS 2500 Texas Drive Suite 100 Irving, Texas 75062 Tel 972-252-5357 Fax 972-252-8958 DATE: 12-9-2021 DATE: 12-9-2021 DRAWN BY: JDJR SHEET NO. 1 1 of SCALE: 1" = 40' CHECKED BY: JDJR JDJR FILE NO. 1219-6-20 FORTWORTH® ZC-21-131 Area M a p Council Districts 2 -Carlos E. Flores 3 - Michael D. Crain U} 4 -Cary Moon ' 5 - Gyna Bivens 9 .. I I . . :.1 . 6 -Jared Williams LU 7 -Leonard Firestone 8-Chris Nettles - 9-Elizabeth M. Beck r Overlay Districts ® Airport Overlay District 1-35W TU PERIPHERAL Arlington 0 DESIGN DISTRICT CONSERVATION DISTRICT-~= Noise Contours DECIBEL 65 70 75 P 80 85 0 1,000 2,000 4,000 Feet Created: 12/14/2021 12:22:51 PM FORTWORTH. ZC-21-131 A TOLLWAY/FREEWAY PRI NCIPALARTER IAL MAJOR ARTERIAL MINOR ARTERIAL \,bcant, Undeveloped, Agricultural Rural Residential Suburban Residential Single Family Residential Manufactured Housing Low Density Residential Medium Density Residential High Dens ity Residential Future Land Use Institutional Neighborhood Commercial General Commercial Light Industrial Heavy Industrial Mixed -Use Industrial Growth Center Infrastructure ez 100 Year Flood Plain Public Park, Recreation, Open Space Private Park, Recreation, Open Space n Lakes and Ponds 475 237.5 0 475 Feet JOHN T WHITE z N A Comprehensive Plan shaA not constitute zoning regulations or astabl is h z on ing district boundaries. (Texas Loca l Government Code, Section 213.005.) Land use designations were approved by Cfly CouncH on March 6, 2018. Crested: 12042021 12:2 1S8 PM FORTWORTH® ZC-21-131 Aerial Photo Map � �e I175 { �'� iyie � i�r �t� .•� I = � _ jf}�J� v''t�_•]Y�� +f � Y t ti F 1 F ' jam+^ � �• �. , � '3b .' � •� .5�- , 6 ek• � 4 ' ' a 1 t, Lj ` A Tj 4 �...-. 7 Ill I a n e e ■ i y� ! r 1,. kt •'Fir rd s. ~� � `x ^--i I - •` Ij •f C!k �Y .� �ai ? ?'�-44 '� I� �,. ~+P � Lyra { S ;INN_ �'�IF'1 .�r T. 'A'� �i. +• ... _ �.° R� 0 295 590 1,180 Feet