Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout(0162) ZC-21-172Date: March 8, 2022 Case Number: ZC-21-172 Zoning Map Amendment Case Manager: Stephen Murray Owner /Applicant: Robert H. Frost Site Location: 100-500 blocks Beach Street Acreage: Request Proposed Use: Industrial Request: From: "B" Two -Family Council District: 4 31.06 acres To: "PD/I" Planned Development for "I" Light Industrial removing certain uses with development standards, site plan included. Recommendation Land Use Compatibility: Requested change is compatible. Comprehensive Plan Consistency: Requested change is not consistent (significant deviation). Staff Recommendation: Denial Zoning Commission Recommendation: Denial by a vote of 5-2 Table of Contents 1. Proiect Description and Background 2. Surrounding Zoning and Land Uses 3. Recent ZoningHistory 4. Public Notification 5. Development Impact Analysis a. Land Use Compatibility b. Comprehensive Plan Consistency 6. Area Zoning Map with 300 ft. Notification Area 7. Area Map 8. Future Land Use Map 9. Aerial Photograph Project Description and Background 14M The subject property is located south of lst Street on the east side of Beach Street. The site is currently vacant and is zoned `B" Two -Family. The applicant is proposing to rezone this property to "PD/I" Planned Development for "I" Light Industrial removing certain uses with development standards, site plan included to allow for the development of industrial and warehouse. There is a significant amount of industrial zoned land east and south of the site. Development challenges exist and reduce the amount of land that can be used for industrial due to water features and extensive floodplain on the east side of the property. The proposed industrial would take advantage of the close proximity to arterials and highways near the site. The site is located near Gateway Park, which is referenced in the Trinity River Strategic Plan. This plan sets the framework for diverse set of needs and desires, and proposes policies that will allow the river system to be a fun, healthy, accessible, sustainable, and economically vibrant place for everyone. Gateway Park is called out specifically in the following strategies: Economic Development • Encourage developers to concentrate new development around existing and future destination points, such as Downtown, Panther Island, Gateway Park, and Marine Creek Lake Health • Promote trail usage along Sycamore Creek, in Cobb Park, in Gateway Park, and along West Fork East to bring more "eyes on the river" and encourage positive perceptions of these river segments In addition, the City Council adopted an updated Gateway Park Master Plan (2002) as an amendment to the Fort Worth Park, Recreation and Open Space Master Plan. One of the goals of the plan is to expand the park. It is worth noting that the City is working with the TRWD and the Texas Parks & Wildlife Department to use property east of the proposal in a park easement swap to support the Panther Island/Central City Flood Control Project. The applicant was notified of this document and provide a map of the proposal. The City does not own the land proposed for future park expansion. Requirement "I" Light Industrial Proposed PD None required if entire block frontage is zoned "FR" through "K;" if the Front Yard block frontage contains a 50 feet residential district or the "BR" or "E" district, the most restrictive district standards apply 10 feet minimum adjacent 0 feet (50 ft supplemental Rear Yard to residentially zoned lot, setback will be provided none otherwise adjacent One or Two Family District Side Yard Interior 5 feet 5 feet None required unless None required unless Corner through lot, then 10 feet through lot, then 10 feet minimum required minimum required Loading Dock Locations Screened from public Loading docks may not ROW directly face public streets Surrounding Zoning and Land Uses North "B" Two -Family / single-family East "K" Heavy Industrial; "J" Medium Industrial / vacant, truck storage South "J" Medium Industrial / vacant West `B" Two -Family / vacant, single-family • None Recent Zoning History Public Notification 300-foot Legal Notifications were mailed on January 28, 2022. The following organizations were notified: (emailed January 26, 2021) M id Organizations Notified Riverside Alliance Streams and Valleys Inc Neighborhoods of East Fort Worth Trinity Habitat for Humanity East Fort Worth, Inc. United Riverside Rebuilding Corporation, Inc. East Fort Worth Business Association Fort Worth ISD * Subject property is not located within a registered Neighborhood Organization Development Impact Analysis Land Use Compatibility The applicant is requesting to change the zoning of this property from `B" Two -Family to "PD/I" Planned Development for all uses in "I" Light Industrial with development standards, site plan included. Surrounding uses vary with single-family to the north and west with vacant land and truck parking to the south and east. Adjacent property to the south and ease is already zoned "K" Heavy Industrial and "J" Medium Industrial. The site is located along two arterials with nearby access to both SH 121 to the north and IH-30 to the south making this site desirable for industrial uses. Industrial zoned development adjacent residentially zoned property will be required to provide a 50 ft. setback, fencing, and a 5 ft. landscaped buffeyard. The proposed zoning is compatible with surrounding land uses. Comprehensive Plan Consistency — Eastside The 2021 Comprehensive Plan currently designates the subject property as "Low -Density Residential" and "Neighborhood Commercial" on the Future Land Use Map. The future land use was changed in 2019. The purpose of the change was specifically to bring more residential development within walking distance of Gateway Park and the Trinity Trails. The proposed "PD/I" zoning does not meet the intent of the Future Land Use Designation in this area. Therefore, the proposed zoning is not consistent with the Comprehensive Plan (significant deviation). Economic Development Plan The 2021 Economic Development Strategic Plan identified four different results to facilitate the success and growth of Fort Worth: 1. High -wage job growth. 2. A more sustainable tax base, driven less by residential property valuation and more by commercial and industrial investment. 3. An economy that capitalizes on high -growth businesses and the creative individuals who fuel them, targeting specific industry classifications. 4. A commitment to "quality of place" throughout the community, including rising home values, new business startups, reduction of blighted areas, and the emergence of walkable corridors with a mixture of residential and commercial developments and related amenities. The proposed zoning request will contribute to items 1 and 2 above. Site Plan Comments The site plan as submitted is in general compliance with the Zoning Ordinance regulations. (Comments made by Platting (Subdivision Ordinance), Transportation/Public Works, Fire, Park & Recreation, and Water Department staff cannot be waived through the Zoning Commission and City Council. Approval of the zoning site plan does not constitute the acceptance of conditions.) lT WORT a -2 1 -1 7 Area zoning Map Applicant: Robert H_ Frost .Address: 100 - 500 blacks Beach Street Zoning From: B Zoning To: PD for "I" Light Industrial uses, removing certain uses and adding development standards Acres: 31.06595298 Mapsco: 64STVVX Sector/District: Eastside Commission Gate: Z9,2022 Contact: 817-892-6226 221 274 301 :114 tra a487 31 3]5 301 215 314 313 Y 34 11 m 315 47 308 3titma 309 0 31 ;}01 213 204 229 a 41Y5 I. 3815 98i9 229 306 1 145 14d 14 149 221 ti me Tvr�$ � � a r G 137 221 13's 132 13$ n 111 103 a vtn 129 241 as 1 09 125 122 120 121 14 13909 lip 3921 r _ "H-N- . \ \'• �� �. �\��� d400 2?3 240 L T 22 AFD Am .. .. 61`•`� JAN -5 GA 3812 i \ \ 3924 '• w 8Libiec `:4,ea 00 11 o iIca_i+gin - 4,4::{I 1,050 Feet V2&1Ed2c 12:30:09 PU 3 7 J% Haltom City ' d91 : ZC-21-172 jo 3 1 a ffinmm m Council Districts 2 - Car bs E. F Iores 3 - Michael D. Crain 4 -Cary Moon 5 - Gyna B Keens 6 - Jared W il liarrics 7-Lean and F ies ton r= 8 - C hF b Nettles 9 - E IL 9 bath M. Beck Overlay Districts F7^71 Airport Overlay District 1-35W TU PERIPHERAL DESIGN DISTRICT 3D CONSERVATION DISTRICT Noise Contours DECIBEL C5 70 T5 93 Hill 11111111,01 loll mill 111111 Will 1 it uuuuu ill, II im U, - I i I ri I i I I I I I I 1 111111, 11 1 111, 111, 1111 on■ in in on Li., ag g. a- .. 9 IRI 1 111, i 1 1. 1 mimill Mrl mill wiluffiNTHE CAealed: V25= 12:30:24 PU ORT WORT - 1-17 k Future Land Use D jr!lr�r: etl,AgAcuIBiral y- Yr^::'i 53en6e r ''anT _- = f Ma)'aar=loadPt3hARK - --- r _}k DeriSf-r ':a � Public Park :_ '+_' S}at5e e- E°� G?e:-iSpace - ---'_.,-:°'aI r=:e se..iee:o ! _'.._ /� 4 1 _=d-__ _}4'i"'o l . ?ACC -CC C ?ACC Feet ACumPh mum.0 3Mn bm dmrk3. Tb xpninp G.-. na or -kblksh xonnp tliahl. ho�ndarYa. dliaa Lovl Go}emmnk Cosa. S.mm "Lo 02.3 kantl -. daa4n b.- xar .gp—d kyCkyc..nd—Minh0,3CM . ����r ����r�� _ _ �� � � � � � �� r�� i �r,��� ��� �. � e .,. _..._ _ — .. ��� -- _ � .� � � � �� . : . . �—� � .. . . , . �� : _ . : , � � .�{ � :�� _ , r . � �,� .. : � + . ..� . � . . . � . � . . . � . .�� y # .� _ • _ ; . . � F w . IL M-�w� . . . . _ _ '' " 4 . . . - .. � � r : � v,�. , . _ . � ,�`� � � _ ' . _ . � � � �, � . . . � .: . . . . � � - — , .� . — � . A� _ {r'�� {_���c# ,� •. . . — - �•Y:P..? Y..� � 1 #�,y�` - �� ` �� ��,`��. , � ���s� ,a r � ��,�,�1 . � 1 � �• . - 'q .s� 1,�.r� .� �i•. , � . '� . r� 5. �5ii��� .. ^ � �� � � - � I �,, py�'� r e�� F��' � 1 �•.�� �� . +"�F� � " 1'�, , * �"� •.'��+� . t � _ .-, �� , �.�� . �. . `.. ,. . ,_.. . . _ � . + � � .� . _ � ��, �.i� � �a :� . . , , _ . ' ..' . _� '� - . � � r . � �y . , �. . . ' y. `� .e� P ' - �;: . n '' ' ._ ' _ ,� . , _ {+�A� � � �� � i,. . , r .'� . . " '�. ' .,.. .. ;'-� ." _ , . . _ r��� F . — Y ^ � � v � �, _ - � � �.` ��- �+� — � �. ---- �� � a � { � n # Y '"� - ` r _ � ` yt; � �.�"� . � �' .,1 .. - - `� �-�. . F , � ���� �� + . 4� - . . .- , . - � , � i � � � . � i� - I�{� �.a. �p� � r �' �� , , d .. - � • r . . ,f ✓,.,f . _ - � — . _ ���..��,�. t � � � � ��►`'�.�,r'`.+��"�� �� �W�� .. . . ' 4 .._L ' _. _ �.�f�;yy,�� #�'-'+� � ' ,� ;�t r `.. . f k ��. �. �}� �,� �`"�' fi• �y` � � � �� - _ ••'. � � ,! 9i ' �t� � � . i � h. � �r� �, � � �� C ��� �� 9� m � I #��'� � �.fi? � ,�'� �1y ` .rf I , ,�,�'`. � a. A t}�i�'. �.�� �ry.� S� +� F.. - # F' � � k � � � * �k ���. _ �" s .� M'�,�� �' .� �*. � �-�'� �'��'��'� �� �- '�'` t; .,, _ I' �}. � a:w,' �Y 4+�` - L� ��y��+'::°'f ���'� �°��` +� � . . � _� . _. - ., � , . � '� � ' fi� � � - - � '� � q� #.� f�+ � r � . �. P + �� / � . • 3; �� �.� ?*/;• .��` � �y � '3.^a�� � �,'E`. p. pi��' � �/ .. - ' . . _ - ' .- ' i , : , . +J - • — .. ,,�,� 1"_ ` F� . �. ��� �``� �� � , Y •J ��,►�r� Y �', . . . ._ . L ., . � ,. . I � . tY' �*'. #� ..r �+�* F.. . } i� �� T� r .. . � ,. ' ��:� � . `�' F�...�. �� �� y�, ��.. ,. �� � f � �. :�• ,. ��" � :� � _ � w��r+' *� } j.�.�; ./� ;�.� �� `^l+�`� �{f,� �I`,`��`.'�r�,���; �,� �� ��,: .. . -.. . �� - . � � _ .. . "�� � '. ; ' F $ a � : �1r . .. ... � .. . -.�` � . � . P . '� " , •' " T '. [ _ " .. �' .":♦ rR��l � !�{�f��� � � �� ��''IP'.+� F .h' _� . ���� ikdl . . . . . . . - ...� . '� �*„ r*r { # � ' . . F�. . � ... � -� •y.,- " . ... �� � . ' � . �fF� f � �� � �� # % �'�� .�.�—" _ . � ir. �.. �:ye ;,k*"- � �,r ""�t y,�� +���'.ia �� F: . � +�� d 9P�k �'y'£ d_�_ _ �`� �°� Fr �' . . r - . � .t _. _ .� ��* , a , � , �F � `F / •� } � yP` � � � � .� . . y � -� _ . y. ¢ �, � 4 ��;` ��5, �� �{, 1, 'k}�; . - � -� _ . � �` �,�� � • '�:�s�,�� � �. �•.��;P� ti .* ���p� .a �q r Y�' � - 4 ¢' _. �` �.�,,�,��, , 1�a�� �� ''�'� ��,�+,aa' i :'.�R•� �,, d � z ' � � �,i ,Jy.�_(""�,:. �t` {�.�r� � e� ry ��'a � "A � ��,�'� � - �� � �.�' . �l � . � ' � i � � � ��� ,� _'�,� , A � �. *��' ��F� k �' � `"` � � '��' ' '' !' . r'r'� t r ��1�``�1►``''� '� �'� ,� �`. �'- �. • � ��,, .r�: yF��. � , ,�'" �1. ,�`"�► � a .. �i1'� ,�� r , 4r f� �'�,� � r� "Frt} � I`���� k f a� �' t ��: • � � , ,...� .� . , . � . �' f ��'�r . ,:��/' � �. . � ' �. r« r �. . � i F ''; !,/ ,-. � �'; + ' � � •. . %� � ,�'�.�+°,�'/�� F� � f, � #��,� .. �#� , , :�� r�� � �! �i� �� � t � � '��t�.�.�� '*'�"�"��� ' �.�r� � ` f r r �� ��' + � ����#4���: � j� � .� `; r��r�: � � � ' # ; � � ���+q,��s�r� �� �,r���; ; � . � ,, s . � ## * +�J"g � -'' $ �." �+ �/ fi„1 �{ �;f :. ,y.�+�` � + i 1 r "�, '��� €.� :f_ "� f+�P k ,.�'� { � � � G�a4Y ,��`��� ���:� ' , �� � ,�, �1I ,�,a�'� � �r''�,� �. ,,��� �i+ j�,� �� � ". � "� � - '''� ��-_ a + ��� � � � �'" ,,- ,�� �� � � �,. F ,, ,,�-k � � .�. . � +' r, � ' .s t r. ,o �5 � � �.� +� i?',��,#� i`'' �,1�'�gv �'� �� '��.�'"' � ;�� �.a � �° �' . � `�� '�°` ,�i i �s+` �'' k f s i `"F'` . � :�, ,, �'�"�"� ��� +��� - � - - - - ar� .1�+�!'� � � �' /►`'�'`' i � + + � 0 ��00 1,000 �,000 Feet ; i i i I i i i ; N O N U CU OWNER/DEVELOPER SCANNELL PROPERTIES 8201 PRESTON ROAD SUITE 725 DALLAS, TEXAS 75225 CONTACT: CHARLES KNOWLTON EMAIL: CHARLESK@SCANNELLPROPERTIES.COM TEL: (214) 686-7933 ENGINEER/SURVEYOR HALFF ASSOCIATES, INC. 1201 NORTH BOWSER ROAD RICHARDSON, TX. 75081 CONTACT: IAN NORFOLK, P.E. EMAIL: INORFOLK@HALFF.COM TEL: (214) 346-6200 TBPE FIRM# F-312 r C � Z RESIDENTIAL m 0 ZONED B p 0 J G) 171 r N RESIDENTIAL D ZONED B BEACH ST. SITE NOTES: m = RESIDENTIAL � R ZONED FIR HATCHED AREA TO BE REZONED AREA LIGHTING - ALL PROVIDED LIGHTING WILL CONFORM TO THE CURRENT FORT WORTH LIGHTING CODE. SIGNAGE - ALL SIGNAGE WILL CONFIRM TO FORT WORTH ARTICLE 4, SIGNS LANDSCAPING - THIS PROJECT WILL COMPLY WITH FORT WORTH LANDSCAPING SECTION 6.301 URBAN FORESTRY - THIS PROJECT WILL COMPLY WITH FORT WORTH URBAN FORESTRY SECTION 6.302 ITIAL )B �- z 0 120' 240' GRAPHIC SCALE - 1"=120' SITE VICINITY MAP 1 "=2000' DIRECTOR OF PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT DATE ZONING CASE NUMBER: ZC-21-172 Q U) In X W U cn Q U) w w o 00 zry � �LL o m L0 LN N Q O O � r U) JW w �o� 1- mZ�LL Q0� � � M 0 of ZQN�- W 3: -j N F F ENN MEN c 0 .Q U N N 0 N C � O � N Of O Z PRELIMNARY FOR INTERIM REVIEW ONLY THESE DOCUMENTS ARE FOR INTERIM REVIEW AND NOT INTENDED FOR REGULATORY APPROVAL, PERMIT, BIDDING OR CONSTRUCTION PURPOSES. THEY WERE PREPARED BY OR UNDER THE SUPERVISION OF: IAN NORFOLK, P.E. 93550 NAME P.E. NO. DATE 08/17/2021 TBPE FIRM #F-312 Project No.: 43435 Issued: 2021-12-30 Drawn By: CAD Checked By: IN Scale: AS NOTED Sheet Title PD SITE PLAN EXHIBIT PD SITE PLAN Sheet Number ZC-21-172 PROPOSED PLANNED DEVELOPMENT DISTRICT December 29, 2021 PROPOSED REQUEST: 1. Modify request for a Planned Development, "PD", under Light Industrial, "I", standards, except as modified herein. 2. Modify the permitted uses as follows: • Permitted Uses (below is a list of all uses permitted in "I" with strike-thru's on uses we could offer to prohibit — open for discussion) o Household Living 0 One dwelling unit when part of a business o Public and Civic Uses v s;h. • • College o Day care center (child or adult) • Government maintenance facility • Government office facility • Museum, library or fine art center • Ambulance dispatch station • Assisted living facility • Blood bank • Care facility • Health services facility, including doctor's office or medical clinic • Hospice • Hospital • • Massage therapy and—sipa Nursing home (with full medical services) • Center, community recreation or welfare • Center, community recreation or welfare (private or non-profit) • Country club (private) • Golf course • Golf driving range • Park or playground (public or private) • Place of worship • Electric power substation (CUP) 30678575v.2 • Telecommunication antenna • Utility transmission or distribution line • Wastewater (sewage) treatment facility • Water supply, treatment or storage facility • Amusement, indoor • n o one „tdoof • Baseball/softball facility; other ball fields (commercial) • Bowling alley • Oti o aer- btisi ess- • Drive-in restaurant or business • Event center or rental hall • Health or recreation club • Indoor recreation • Lodge or civic club • Museum/cultural facility • Restaurant, caf6, cafeteria • Sexually o6effted business • Stable, commercial, riding, boarding or rodeo arena • Swimming pool, commercial • Theater, drive-in • Theater, movie theater or auditorium • Vendor, food, mobile vendor food court • Short term home rental • Bank, financial institution • Offices • Antique shop • Appliance, sales, supply or repair • Bakery • Barber or beauty shop • Boat rental or sales • Book, stationary stores or newsstand • Burglar alarm sales and service • Caterer or wedding service • Clothing/wearing apparel sales, new • Clothing/wearing apparel sales, used • Convenience store • Copy store or commercial print without off -set printing Page 2 30678575v.2 • Dance studio • Dressmaking, custom; millinery shop • Duplicating services • Feed store, no processing/milling • Firewood sales • Furniture sales, new and used (office and residential) in a building • Furniture upholstery, refinishing or resale • General merchandise store • Greenhouse or plant nursery • Grocery store, meat market • Gunsmithing, repairs or sales • Home improvement store • Interior decorating • Kennel • Large retail store • Laundry or dry cleaning collection office • Laundry, dry cleaning or washeteria • Leather goods shop • Liquor or package store • Locksmith • Medical supplies/equipment sales or rental • Newspaper distribution center • Optician • P., shy • Pharmacy (drug store) • Photograph, portrait/camera shop or photo finishing • Recording studio • Retail sales, general • Saddle or harness, repair or sales • Shoe shine shop • Studio, art or photography • Tailor, clothing or apparel shop • Taxidermist shop • Veterinary clinic w/indoor kennels • Veterinary clinic w/outdoor kennels • Auto parts supply, retail • Automotive repair; paint and body shop • Car wash, full or self service • Gasoline sales • Mobile home or- mai+afaetufed hettsing sales • Parking area or garage, storage commercial or auxiliary • Recreational vehicle (RV) sales/service Page 3 30678575v.2 • Service station • Vehicle sales or rental; including automobiles, motorcycles, boats or trailers • Vehicle steam cleaning o Light Industrial • Assaying • Assembly of pre -manufactured parts, except for vehicles, trailers, airplanes or mobile homes • Bottling works, milk or soft drinks • Carpet and rug cleaning • Gfematefitim • Data center • Electroplating • Fabricating or manufactured housing, temporary or office building • Food processing (no slaughtering) • Furniture or cabinet repair or construction • Furniture sales, with outside storage/display (new/used) • Galvanizing, small utensils • Machine shops • Manufacture of artificial flowers, ornaments, awnings, tents, bags, cleaning/polishing preparations, boats under 28 ft. in length, brooms or brushes, buttons and novelties, canvas products, clothing, suits, coats or dresses for wholesale trade • Manufacture of aluminum, brass or other metals or from bone, paper, rubber, leather and plastics • Monument/marble works, finishing and carving only • Monument works, stone • Outdoor sales and storage including yards, contractors, lumber or storage, automobiles, storage yards, building materials • Paint mixing or spraying • Paper box manufacture • Pattern shop • Printing, lithographing, book -binding, newspapers or publishing • Rubber stamping, shearing/punching • Rubber stamp manufacture • Sheet metal shop • Warehouse or bulk storage o Transportation Uses Page 4 30678575v.2 • Railroad t > team, nr, .loading-aeks. loading o storage • Terminal, truck, freight, rail or water • Recycling center, indoor only with no outdoor sorting or storage activity o Wholesale Related Uses • Wholesale: bakery, produce market or wholesale house • Wholesale office or sample room o Other Uses • 1 Yost, water- ftaetufe ponds and r ,.dtietion • Gas drilling and pr-eduefie • Urban agriculture • Community garden o Accessoa Uses • Satellite antenna (dish) • Storage or display outside • Affmsement, outdoor- (temporary) • Batch plant, concrete or asphalt (temporary) • Trailer, portable; sales, construction or storage 3. Propose the following development standards: DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS Front Yard 50 feet - Rear Yard 0 feet Side yard Interior 5 feet Corner None required unless through lot, then 10 feet minimum required 4. Additional modifications: a) Loading dock locations: Loading docks may not directly face public streets. b) Parking: i. Industrial buildings shall provide 1 parking space per 2,000 square feet of gross floor area or one space per three employees, whichever is greater. ii. Warehouse buildings require one parking space per four employees. c) Landscape and buffers: For industrial uses, 4% of net site area or landscape of 30-foot depth along public right of ways is required. Redbud trees shall be used for required small canopy trees throughout the Property. Page 5 30678575v.2