HomeMy WebLinkAboutContract 24129 CITY SECRETARY
CONTRACT NO.
STATE OF TEXAS § TAX ABATEMENT AGREEMENT BETWEEN
COUNTY OF TARRANT § THE CITY OF FORT WORTH AND
CITY OF FORT WORTH § BEN E. KEITH COMPANY
This Tax Abatement Agreement (this "Agreement") is entered
into by and between the City of Fort Worth, Texas (the "City") ,
duly acting herein by and through its City Manager, and the Ben
E. Keith Company ("Owner") , a Texas partnership, duly acting by
and through its authorized officers .
WHEREAS, the City has adopted a resolution stating that it
elects to be eligible to participate in tax abatement; and
WHEREAS, on the 17th day of February, 1998, the City Council
of the City of Fort Worth, Texas ("City Council") adopted a
Policy Statement: Tax Abatement for Qualifying Development
Projects (the "Policy Statement") , attached hereto and
incorporated herein as Exhibit "A"; and
WHEREAS, the Policy Statement constitutes appropriate
"guidelines and criteria" governing tax abatement agreements to
be entered into by the City as contemplated by the Texas Tax
Code, as amended (the "Code") ; and
WHEREAS, on the 7th day of July, 1998, the Fort Worth City
Council adopted Ordinance No. S/Z. establishing Tax Abatement
Reinvestment Zone No. 30 ("the Zone") ; and
WHEREAS, Owner owns certain real property, more particularly
described in Exhibit "B" attached hereto and incorporated herein
by reference (the "Premises") , located totally within the Zone;
and
WHEREAS, on the 12th day of May, - 1998, Owner submitted an
application for tax abatement with various attachments to the
City concerning the contemplated use of the Premises (the
"Application for Tax Abatement") , attached hereto. and
incorporated herein as Exhibit "C"; and
WHEREAS, the contemplated use of the Premises, the Required
Improvements (as hereinafter defined) to the Premises as set
forth in this Agreement, and the other terms hereof are
consistent with encouraging development of said Zone in
accordance with the purposes for its creation and are in
compliance with the Policy Statement and the Ordinance and
similar guidelines and criteria adopted by the City and all
applicable law; and
W��,,nn 0(i���yR 1!UM
WHEREAS, the city Council finds that the terms of this
Agreement, and the Premises and Required Improvements, satisfy
the eligibility criteria of the policy Statement; and
WHEREAS, written notice that the City intends to enter into
this Agreement, along with a copy of this Agreement has been
furnished, in the manner prescribed by the Code, to the presiding
officers of the governing bodies of each of the taxing units in
which the Premises is located.
NOW, THEREFORE, the City and Owner for and in consideration
of the premises and the promises contained herein, do hereby
contract, covenant and agree as follows:
I.
OWNER' S COVENANTS
A. owner shall construct, or cause to be constructed, on
and within the Premises certain improvements (the "Required
Improvements") M consisting of 412, 000-sq. ft. food
distribution facility, and (ii) having a cost upon completion of
at least Twenty Eight Million Dollars ($28, 000, 000) including
site development costs. The kind, number and location of the
Required Improvements are more particularly described in the
Application for Tax Abatement. As long as the conditions in the
first sentence of this Paragraph A are met and the Required
Improvements are used for the purposes and in the manner
described in the Application for Tax Abatement, minor variations
in the Required Improvements from the description provided in the
Application shall not be an Event of Default.
B. owner covenants to substantially complete construction
of all of the Required Improvements on or before December 31,
1999 (12/31/99) .
C. owner covenants that during the term of the abatement
(as defined in Paragraph III .E. hereof) owner shall cause to be
located on the Premises new tangible personal property having a
cost of at least One Million Dollars ($1, 000, 000) , excluding
inventory and supplies .
D. Owner covenants that the Required Improvements shall be
constructed and the Premises shall be used in accordance with the
description of the project set forth in the Application for Tax
Abatement. The Owner covenants to comply with and satisfy all of
the provisions and requirements for the project as set forth in
the Application for Tax Abatement, including but not limited to
2
(i) the description and location of the Required Improvements;
(ii) the activities to be performed; (iii) the eligibility
criteria for the Required Improvements; (iv) the impact from
construction including amounts to be spent with Fort Worth
contractors, subcontractors and certified Minority Business
Enterprises and Women Business Enterprises; (v) the employment
impact from permanent employment, including the number of jobs,
number of jobs to be held by Fort Worth residents and number of
jobs to be held by Inner City residents; (vi) the cost and fiscal
impact of the Required Improvements; and (vii) the dollar amount
and type of annual supplier and professional service contracts
that will be awarded to both Fort Worth companies and certified
Minority Business Enterprises and Women Business Enterprises .
E. Owner covenants that throughout the term of the
abatement, the Required Improvements shall be operated and
maintained for the purposes set forth herein so that the uses of
the Premises shall be consistent with the general purposes of
encouraging development or redevelopment of the Zone, except as
otherwise authorized or modified by this Agreement.
Ii .
GENERAL PROVISIONS
A. The City has adopted guidelines and criteria governing
tax abatement agreements for the City and may enter into this
Agreement containing the terms set forth herein.
B. Procedures followed by the City generally conform to the
requirements of the Code, and have been and will be undertaken in
coordination with Owner' s corporate, public, employee, and
business relations requirements .
C. The Premises are not an improvement project financed by
tax increment bonds .
D. Neither the Premises nor any of the Improvements covered
by this Agreement are owned or leased by any member of the City
Council, any member of the City Plan or Zoning commission of the
City or any member of the governing body of any taxing units
joining in or adopting this Agreement.
E. This Agreement is subject to rights of holders of out-
standing bonds of the City.
3
F. In the event of any conflict between the City zoning
ordinances, or other City ordinances or regulations, and this
Agreement, such ordinances or regulations shall control .
G. A portion or all of the Premises and/or Improvements may
be eligible for complete or partial exemption from ad valorem
taxes, as a result of existing law or future legislation. This
Agreement is not to be construed as evidence that no such exemp-
tions apply to the Premises and/or Improvements .
III .
ABATEMENT TERMS AND CONDITIONS
A. The City hereby grants a real property tax abatement
("Abatement") to owner relative to Owner' s Premises and the
Improvements, such Abatement to be subject to the following terms
and conditions .
B. The Abatement shall be based upon the increase in value
of the Premises and the Improvements over their value on January
1, 1998, the year in which this Agreement is executed, as
follows :
Up to seventy-five percent (75%) of the increase in value
resulting from construction of the Required Improvements
based upon the abatement schedule in the application for tax
abatement (Attachment "C") , such increase in value subject
to abatement in any one year being limited to no more than
Twenty Eight Million Dollars ($28, 000, 000) .
C. Owner shall have the right to protest and contest any
or all appraisals or assessments of the Premises and/or
Improvements .
D. The term of the Abatement (the "Term") shall begin on
January 1 of the year designated in writing by the Owner (which
designation must be received by January 31, 2000) but no earlier
than on January 1 of t i
'he year following the year n which the
Certificate of occupancy is issued (the "Beginning Date") and,
unless sooner terminated as herein provided, shall end on the
December 31st immediately preceding the tenth (10th) anniversary
of the Beginning Date. Unless otherwise designated by Owner, the
term of the Abatement shall begin on January 1 of the year
following the year in which the Certificate of occupancy is
issued,.
4
E. The City acknowledges receipt from owner of the required
application for Tax Abatement fee of 10 of project cost, not to
exceed $15, 000. If construction on the project is begun within
one year from July 7, 1998 (with or without a tax abatement) ,
such fee shall be creditable in full to the benefit of owner
against any permit, impact, inspection or other lawful fee re-
quired by the City in connection with the project, and any
remaining amounts shall be refunded to Owner.
IV.
RECORDS, AUDITS AND EVALUATION OF PROJECT
A. Subject to applicable law governing financial disclosure
by the Owner, the City shall have the right to review the
financial condition of the project to determine compliance with
this Agreement. The City shall annually (or such other times
deemed appropriate by the City) evaluate the project to insure
compliance with this Agreement. On or before March 1st of every
year during the life of the agreement, owner shall provide
information and documentation which details owner' s compliance
with each applicable term of the agreement. Failure to provide
this information shall be considered an event of default. The
information shall include, but not be limited to, the following:
(i) the number and dollar amounts of all construction
contracts and subcontracts awarded on the project, specifying
which companies are Fort Worth entities;
(ii) the total number of employees who work on the
premises, the number of employees who reside in Fort Worth, and
the number of employees who reside in designated "Inner City"
area. These jobs shall be reported in job classifications
appropriate to the employees;
(iii) the gross dollars spent on supplier and profes-
sional service contracts, with detail sufficient to demonstrate
the amounts by contract awarded and performed by Fort Worth
individuals and entities;
(iv) the dollar amount of both construction and supply
and service contracts awarded to Minority Business Enterprises
and Women Business Enterprises; and
(v) if the dollars or percentages do not equal the
original (as detailed in Exhibit C, "Application for Tax
Abatement) or city Council modified requirements of this
Agreement, owner shall explain the reason for the failure to meet
the requirements and state a recommended course of rectification.
5
B The city shall make a decision and rule on the eligi-
bility of the project for tax abatement, based on the information
furnished each year, on or before August 1 of the taxable year
and shall so notify the Owner. The City Council' s decision on
the matter shall be binding, final and not appealable, except for
arbitrary and capricious acts and actions, gross negligence or
willful misconduct, and any appeal shall be under the substantial
evidence rule.
C. During normal office hours throughout the Term of this
Agreement, providing reasonable notice is. given to owner, the
City shall have access to the Premises by City employees for the
purpose of inspecting the Premises and the Required Improvements
to ensure that the Required Improvements or repairs are made in
accordance with the specifications and conditions of this
Agreement and to verify that the conditions of this Agreement are
being complied with.
V.
BREACH
A. In the event that (i) the Required Improvements for
which an abatement has been granted are not completed in
accordance with this Agreement; or (ii) the schedule of
Improvements listed in Paragraph B of Article I of this Agreement
is not satisfied; or (iii) owner allows its ad valorem real
property taxes with respect to the Premises or Improvements, or
its ad valorem taxes with respect to the tangible personal to
become delinquent and fails to timely and properly follow the
legal procedures for protest and/or contest of any such ad
valorem real property or tangible personal property taxes; or
(iv) owner breaches any of the other terms or conditions of this
Agreement, then owner shall be in default of this Agreement (an
"Event of Default") . Should an Event of Default occur, the City
shall give owner written notice of such Event of Default and if
Owner has not cured such Event of Default within ninety (90) days
of said written notice, this Agreement may be terminated by the
City; provided, however, that if such Event of Default is not
reasonably susceptible of cure within such ninety (90) day period
and Owner has commenced and is pursuing the cure of same, then
after first advising city Council of the efforts to cure same,
Owner may utilize an additional ninety (90) days . Time in
addition to the foregoing 180 days may be authorized by the City
Council . As liquidated damages for an Event of Default after the
expiration of the applicable notice and cure periods, all taxes
which otherwise would have been paid to the City for each year
when an Event of Default existed, without the benefit of
6
Abatement (after taking into account any applicable exemptions)
and penalties and interest thereon charged at the statutory rate
for delinquent taxes as determined by Section 33. 01 of the Code,
as in effect at the time of the payment of such penalties and
interest, for each such year for which such taxes were abated,
will become a debt to the City. Such amount shall be due, owing
. and paid to the city within sixty (60) days of the expiration of
the above-mentioned applicable cure period(s) as the sole and
exclusive remedy of the City, subject to any and all lawful
offsets, settlements, deductions, or credits to which owner may
be entitled. The parties acknowledge that actual damages in the
event of default and termination would be speculative and diffi-
cult to determine.
B. Notwithstanding the foregoing paragraph, if the City
and owner mutually determine that the development or use of the
Premises or Required Improvements as contemplated herein is no
longer appropriate or feasible or that a higher or better use is
preferable, the parties may terminate this Agreement by a writing
signed by both parties, the period of Abatement shall expire as
of the effective date of the termination, there ' shall be no
recapture of amounts previously abated, and neither party shall
have any further rights or obligations hereunder.
VI .
EFFECT OF SALE, ASSIGNMENT OR LEASE OF PROPERTY
The abatement shall vest in owner and cannot be assigned to
a new owner or lessee of all or a portion of the Pre*mises and/or
Improvements, and any such assignment shall be grounds for
termination of this Agreement and the tax abatement hereunder
upon ten (10) days' written notice from the city to owner.
VII .
NOTICE
All notices called for or required by this Agreement shall
be addressed to the following, or such other party or address as
either party designates in writing, by certified mail postage
prepaid or by hand delivery:
OWNER: CITY:
Mel Cockrell City Manager
Ben E. Keith Management Trust 1000 Throckmorton Street
601 East 7 th Street Fort Worth, Texas 76102
7
P.O. Box 2628
Fort Worth, Texas 76113
VIII .
CITY COUNCIL AUTHORIZATION
This Agreement was authorized by the City Council at its
meeting on the 7th day of July, 1998, by Council. approving Mayor
and Council Communication No. C-16886 authorizing the City
Manager to execute this Agreement on behalf of the City.
IX.
SEVERABILITY
In the event any section, subsection, paragraph, 'sentence,
phrase or word is held invalid, illegal or unconstitutional, the
balance of this Agreement shall stand, shall be enforceable and
shall be read as if the parties intended at all times to delete
said invalid section, subsection, paragraph, sentence, phrase or
word. In the event that (i) the Term of the Abatement with
respect to any property is longer than allowed by law, or (ii)
the Abatement applies to a broader classification of property
than is allowed by law, then the Abatement shall be valid with
respect to the classification of property abated hereunder, and
the portion of the Term, that is allowed by law.
X.
ESTOPPEL CERTIFICATE
Any party hereto may request an estoppel certificate from
another party hereto so long as the certificate is requested in
connection with a bona fide business purpose. The certificate,
which if requested will be addressed to the Owner, shall include,
but not necessarily be limited to, statements that this Agreement
is in full force and effect without default (or if default exists
the nature of default and curative action, which should be under-
taken to cure same) , the remaining term of this Agreement, the
levels and remaining term of the Abatement in effect, and such
other matters reasonably requested by the party (ies) to receive
the certificates .
XI .
OWNER STANDING
8
Owner, as a party to this Agreement, shall be deemed a
proper and necessary party in any litigation questioning or
challenging the validity of this Agreement or any of the
underlying ordinances, resolutions, or city Council actions
authorizing same and owner shall be entitled to intervene in said
litigation.
XII .
APPLICABLE LAW
This Agreement shall be construed under the laws of the
State of Texas . Venue for any action under this Agreement shall
be the State District Court of Tarrant County, Texas . This
Agreement is performable in Tarrant County, Texas .
XIIII .
RECORDATION OF AGREEMENT
A certified copy of this Agreement in recordable form shall
be recorded in the Deed Records of Tarrant County, Texas.
XIV.
AMENDMENT
This Agreement may be modified by the parties hereto to
include other provisions which could have originally been
included in this Agreement or to delete provisions that were not
originally necessary. to this Agreement pursuant to the procedures
set forth in Title 3, Chapter 312 of the Code.
EXECUTED this day of 5 1998, by
the City.
EXECUTED this day of 1998, by
the Ben E. Keith Company.
AT ST: CITY OF FORT WARTH, TEXAS
By:
City Secretary Assistant city Manager
e --- I & M
Contract Authorization
rl- ri - qe 9
Date
APPROVED AS TO FORM AND LEGALITY:
Assistant City Atto ey
Date: �- 02,
ATTEST: Ben E. Keith Company
By:
Title: W E FiiYlffC-1:& U'`- CL k'
10
STATE OF TEXAS §
COUNTY OF TARRANT §
BEFORE ME, the undersigned authority, on this day personally
appeared Mike Groomer, Assistant City Manager of the CITY OF FORT
WORTH, a municipal corporation, known to me to be the person and
officer whose name is subscribed to the foregoing instrument, and
acknowledged to me that the same was the act of the said CITY OF
FORT WORTH, TEXAS, a municipal corporation, that he was duly
authorized to perform the same by appropriate resolution of the
City Council of the city of Fort Worth and that he. executed the
same as the act of the said City for the purposes and
consideration therein expressed and in the capacity therein
stated.
GIVEN UNDER MY HAND AND SEAL OF ICE this day of
jht&41A A- 1998 .
U
Notary Public in and for
PATRICIA A.GARCIA the State of Texas
NOTARY PUBLIC
rl State of Texas
Comm.EXP.03-31-2001 Notary' s Printed Name
STATE OF TEXAS §
COUNTY OF TARRANT §
BEFORE ME, the undersigned authority, on this day personally
appeared 14EL (Yoe Company, a Texas
CDC of Ben E. Keith
partnership, known to me to be the person whose name is
subscribed to the foregoing instrument, and acknowledged to me
that he executed the same for the purposes and consideration
therein expressed, in the capacity therein stated and as the act
and deed of said partership.
R MY HAND AND SEAL OF ICE this day
'11s
of _=r 1998 .
Notary ry P
otary Pub in and for
P
PAM GILMORE the State of Texas
I vv uff&
Notary Public
STATE OF TEXAS
My Comm.Exp.09115/99
Of Notary' s Printed Name
My commission Expires: 19 C�
BEN E. K8TH ComPANY
CERTIFICATE OF AUTHORITY
L the undersigned duly-elected and acting corporate Secretary of Ben E. Keith
Company, a Texas corporation,hereby certify that:
® Ben E.Keith Company is duly formed and active under the laws of the State of
Texas.
® The primary office of the corporation is at 601 East Seventh Street,Fort Worth,
TX 76102(Mailing address:P.O.Box 2628,Fort Worth,TX 76113).
® In addition to its legal name,Ben E. Keith Company does business under the
assumed names"Ben E.Keith Foods"and"Ben E.Keith Beers".
® The Chief Financial Officer of Ben E.Keith Company has,by virtue of his office,
full authority on behalf of the corporation to seek and obtain tax abatements for
the corporation and to execute agreements establishing the terms and conditions
of those abatements.
® Mel Cockrell is the duly-elected and acting Chief Financial Officer of Ben E.
Keith Company.
® That I have,by virtue of my office,the authority to make the certifications set
forth herein.
To which I set my hand and the seal of the corporation this day of
1998.
S.D. Greenlee
Corporate Secretary
i
EXHIBIT "A"
Policy Statement
CITY OF FORT WORTH
POLICY STATEMENT:
TAX ABATEMENT FOR QUALIFYING
DEVELOPMENT PROJECTS 2Z11
I. GENERAL PURPOSE AND OBJECTIVES
Certain types of investment result in the creation of new jobs, new income and provide for
positive economic growth and inner-city economic stabilization which is beneficial to the City as
a whole. The City of Fort Worth is committed to the promotion of high quality development in
all parts of the City and improvement in the quality of life for its citizens.
The City of Fort Worth will, on a case-by-case basis, give consideration to the granting of
property tax incentives to eligible residential, commercial, and industrial development projects.
It is the policy of the City of Fort Worth that consideration of eligible projects will be provided
in accordance with the guidelines and criteria outlined in this document. Texas law authorizes
the City of Fort Worth to grant tax abatement on the value added to a particular property by a
specific development project which meets the economic goals and objectives of the City, and the
requirements of the statute (Vernon's Tax Code Ann. Section 312.001, et. seq.).
As mandated by state law, this policy applies to the owners of real property. It is not the
policy of the City of Fort Worth to grant property tax abatement,to any development
project for which a building permit has been previously issued by the City's Department of
Development. Nothing in the policy shall be construed as an obligation by the City of Fort
Worth to approve any tax abatement application.
Although all applications which meet the eligibility criteria(Section 111.) of this policy statement
will be reviewed, it is the objective of the City of Fort Worth to encourage applications from
projects that:
(a) are located in enterprise zones or other designated target areas; or
(b) result in a development with little or no additional cost to the City; or
(c) result in 1,000 or more new jobs, with a commitment to hire Fort Worth and inner city
residents.
11. DEFINITIONS
"Abatement"means the full or partial exemption from ad valorem taxes on eligible properties for
a period of up to ten years and an amount of up to 100% of the increase in appraised value (as
reflected on the certified tax roll of the appropriate county appraisal district) resulting from
improvements begun after the execution of the tax abatement agreement. Eligible properties
must be located in a reinvestment zone.
"Reinvestment Zone"is an area designated as such by the City of Fort Worth or State of Texas in
accordance with the Texas Property Redevelopment and Tax Abatement Act, Sections 312.001
through 312.209 of the Tax Code.
"Residential Development Project" is a development project which proposes to construct or
renovate multi-family residential living units on property that is (or meets the requirements to be)
zoned multi-family as defined by the City of Fort Worth Zoning Ordinance.
"Fort Worth Company" is a business which has a principal office located within the city limits of
Fort Worth.
"Minority Business Enterprise (MBE) and Women Business Enterprise (WBE)" is a minority or
women owned business that has received certification as either a MBE or WBE by either the
North Texas Regional Certification Agency (NTRCA) or the Texas Department of
,Transportation(TxDOT),Highway Division.
"Capital Investment" includes only real property improvements such as new facilities and
structures, site improvements, facility expansion, and facility modernization. Capital investment
does NOT include land acquisition costs and/or any existing improvements, or personal property
(such as machinery, equipment, and/or supplies and inventory).
"Facility Expansion" is anew permanent real property improvement such as a building or
buildings constructed to provide additional square footage to accommodate increased space
requirements of a Fort Worth company.
"Facility Modernization" is a new permanent real property improvement under taken to provide
increased productivity for a new or existing Fort Worth company.
"Supply and Service Expenses" are discretionary expenses incurred during the normal
maintenance and operation activities of a business.
III. ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA
A. RESIDENTIAL PROJECT ELIGIBILITY
A residential development project is eligible for property tax abatement if:
1. The project is located in any of the following census tracts: 1002.02, 1010,
1011, 1016, 1017, 1018, 1019 (partial), 1025, 1028 (partial), 1029, 1030,
1031, 1033, 1035, 1036.01, 1037.01, 1038, 1040, 1041 (partial) (see Map-
Exhibit"A"); AND
2. a. The project will construct or renovate no less than 50 residential
living units of which no less than 20% shall be affordable (as defined
by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development) to
persons with incomes at or below 80%of median family income; OR
b. The project has a minimum capital investment of$5 million
(excluding acquisition costs for land and any existing
improvements).
-2-
111. ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA
B. COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL ELIGIBILITY
1. New Projects
In order to be eligible for property tax abatement, a new
commercial/industrial development project must satisfy one of the
following three criteria:
a. Upon completion will have a minimum capital investment of $10
million and commits to hire an agreed upon percentage of residents
from an eligible inner city census tract (as identified on Exhibit
"A") for full time employment.; OR
b. Is located in the "inner city" (as identified on Exhibit "A") or
property immediately adjacent to the major thoroughfares which
serve as boundaries to any of these inner city census tracts and
commits to hire an agreed upon percentage of residents from an
eligible inner city census tract(as identified on Exhibit"A") for full
time employment.; OR
C. Is located outside of the "inner city", has a minimum capital
investment of less than $10 million, and commits to hire an agreed
upon percentage of residents from an eligible inner city census tract
(as identified on Exhibit"A")for full time employment.
2. Existing Business Expansion and/or Modernization
In order to be eligible for property tax abatement, a facility expansion
and/or modernization by an existing commercial/industrial business
a. Upon completion will have a minimum capital investment of $10
million.; OR
b. Must result in increased employment for which the business
commits to hire and retain an agreed upon percentage of residents
from an eligible inner city census tract (as identified on Exhibit
"A") for new, full time positions; AND
C. Must have a minimum capital investment of(1) $500,000, OR (2)
an amount equal to or greater than 25% of the appraised value, as
certified by the appropriate appraisal district, of real property
improvements on the property for the year in which the abatement
is requested.
C. PROOF TESTS
1. Building Permits
No tax abatement will be granted to any development project which has
applied for or received a building permit from the City's Department of
Development.
-3-
2. Evidence of Need for Tax Abatement
The applicant must provide evidence to substantiate and justify the tax
abatement request including (but not limited to) an analysis demonstrating
the tax abatement is necessary for the financial viability of the project.
IV. ABATEMENT GUIDELINES
The tax abatement agreement must provide that the applicant:
(1) Hire Fort Worth residents for an agreed upon percentage (at least 25%) of new full
time jobs to be created and make a good faith effort to hire 100% Fort Worth
residents for all new jobs created as a result of the abatement,
(2) Commit to hire an agreed upon percentage of Fort Worth residents from an eligible
inner city census tract (as identified on Exhibit "A") for all new jobs created as a
result of the project. The agreed upon percentage shall be determined by negotiation.
(3) Utilize Fort Worth companies for an agreed upon percentage of the total costs for
construction and Supply and Service Contracts, and
(4) Utilize Minority and Women owned Business Enterprises (M&WBEs) for an agreed
upon percentage of the total costs for construction and supply and service contracts in
the manner provided in the City of Fort Worth's Minority and Women Business
Enterprise ordinance.
In addition to the above,the abatement must comply with the following guidelines:
A. State law prohibits abatement of taxes levied on inventory, supplies or the existing
tax base. City policy is not to abate taxes on personal property located within Fort
Worth prior to the date of the tax abatement agreement.
B. Unless otherwise specified in the agreement, the amount of the taxes to.be abated
shall in no event exceed the amount of the capital investment (as specified in the
application) multiplied by the City's tax rate in effect for the year in which the
calculation is made.
C. In certain cases, the City may consider a tax abatement application from the
owner of real property who serves as a landlord or lessor for a development
project which meets the eligibility criteria of this section.
D. The City may consider an application from the owner or,lessee of real property
requesting abatement of real and or personal property owned or leased by a
certificated air carrier on the condition that the certificated air carrier make
specific real property improvements or lease real property improvements for a
term of 10 years or more.
E. For an eligible development project to be considered for tax abatement, the
"Application for Tax Abatement" form must be completed and submitted to the
Office of Economic Development.
-4-
F. An application fee must accompany the application. The fee is calculated at the
lesser of: (i) 1% of the project capital investment, or(ii) $15,000.
If construction on the project is begun on the site specified in the application
within a one (1) year period from the application submittal date (with or without a
tax abatement), this fee shall be credited to any permit, impact, inspection or any
other lawful fee required by the City of Fort Worth. If the project is not
constructed on the site specified in the application or if construction takes place at
the specified site more than one (1) year after the application submittal date, the
application fee shall not be refunded or otherwise credited.
G. If requested, the applicant must provide evidence that there are no delinquent
property taxes due on the property on which the development project is to occur.
H. The tax abatement agreement shall limit the uses of property consistent with the
general purpose of encouraging development or redevelopment of the zone during
the period that property tax abatements are in effect.
1. Tax abatement may only be granted for projects located in a reinvestment or
enterprise zone. For eligible projects not currently located in such a zone,the City
Council may choose to so designate the applicant's property in order to allow for a
tax abatement.
J. The owners of all projects receiving tax abatement shall properly maintain the
property to assure the long term economic viability of the project.
V. PROCEDURAL STEPS
Each request for property tax abatement shall be processed according to the following
procedural guidelines.
A. Application Submission:
Provided that the project meets the criteria detailed in Section III of this policy,
the Applicant must complete and submit a City of Fort Worth "Application For
Tax Abatement" form (with required attachments) and pay the appropriate
application fee.
B. Application Review and Evaluation:
The Economic Development Office will review the application for accuracy and
completeness. Once complete,the application will be evaluated based on:
1. Types of new jobs created, including respective wage rates, and
employee benefits packages such as health insurance, day care
provisions, retirement package(s), transportation assistance, and any
other.
2. Percent of new jobs committed to Fort Worth residents.
3. Percent of new jobs committed to Fort Worth"Inner City"residents.
-5-
4. Percent of construction contracts committed to:
Worth firms, and
a Fort rth based f
b. Minority and Women owned Business Enterprises (MBEs and VvTBEs)-
5. Percent of supply and service contract expenses committed to:
a. Fort Worth based firms, and
b. Minority and Women owned Business Enterprises (MBEs and VvBEs).
6. The project's increase in the value of the tax base.
7. Costs to.the City (such as infrastructure participation, etc.).
8. Other items which may be negotiated by the City and the applicant.
Based upon the outcome of the evaluation, the Economic Development Office
may present the application to the City Council's Expanding Economic
Opportunities Committee.
C. Consideration by Council Committee
Should the Economic Development Office present the application to the City
Council's Expanding Economic Opportunities Committee,.the Committee will
consider the application at an open meeting. The Committee may:
(1) Approve the application. Staff will then incorporate the application into a
tax abatement agreement which will be sent to the City Council with the
Committee's recommendation to approve the agreement;or
(2) Request modifications to the application. Economic Development staff
will discuss the suggested modifications with the applicant and then, if the
requested modifications are made, resubmit the modified application to the
Committee for consideration; or
(3) Deny the application. The applicant may appeal the Committee's finding
by requesting the City Council to: (a) disregard the Committee's finding
and (b) instruct city staff to incorporate the application into a tax
abatement agreement for future consideration by the City Council.
D. Consideration by the City Council
The City Council retains sole authority to approve or deny any tax abatement
agreement and is under no obligation to approve any tax abatement application or
tax abatement agreement. The City of Fort Worth is under no obligation to
provide tax abatement in any amount or value to any applicant.
E. Effective Date for Approved Agreements
All tax abatements approved by the City Council will become effective on
January I of the year following the year in which a Certificate of Occupancy (CO)
is issued for the qualifying development project (unless otherwise specified in the
tax abatement agreement). Unless otherwise specified in the agreement,'taxes
levied during the construction of the project shall be due and payable'.
-6-
VI. RECAPTURE
If the terms of the tax abatement agreement are not met, the City Council has the right to
cancel or amend the abatement agreement. In the event of cancellation, the recapture of
abated taxes shall be limited to the year(s) in which the default occurred or continued.
VII. INSPECTION AND FINANCIAL VERIFICATION
The terms of the agreement shall include the City of Fort Worth's right to: (1) review and
verify the applicant's financial statements in each year during the life of the agreement
prior to granting a tax abatement in any given year, (2) conduct an on site inspection of
the project in each year during the life of the abatement to verify compliance with the
terms of the tax abatement agreement.
Vlll. EVALUATION
Upon completion of construction of the facilities, the City shall no less than annually
evaluate each project receiving abatement to insure compliance with the terms of the
agreement. Any incidents of non-compliance will be reported to all affected taxing units.
On or before March 31" of every year during the life of the agreement, any
individual or entity receiving a tax abatement from the City of Fort Worth shall
provide information and documentation which details the property owner's
compliance with the terms of the respective agreement and shall certify that the
owner is in compliance with each applicable term of the agreement. Failure to
report this information and to provide the required certification by the above
deadline shall result in any taxes abated in the prior year being due and payable.
IX. EFFECT OF SALE, ASSIGNMENT OR LEASE OF PROPERTY
No tax abatement rights may be sold, assigned or leased unless otherwise specified in the
tax abatement agreement. Any sale, assignment or lease of the property which is not
permitted in the tax abatement agreement results in cancellation of the agreement and
recapture of any taxes abated after the date on which an unspecified assignment occurred.
i
�,I
N e ,� MM ,1•x ;1.P�PR �,. .
i■
!�_rE•�j�.��i�;.r�r ''!1 =rj���
/r� • �.�� ? - ��f� �9IIII�11 r v�v •� °du7 iii ,�•,r rIl/ • �
VQ M
r�� ' I • `���3�"!1�+_y t� 61�])!F►IIiC�����' ��frri�ll��i=Tl�`I. �' r r
• �_ ��;..I�re rWRIN� ' hp�n,W� nlf' It�C .
\� �-.�.�,L_t�\���■��1[iL������ ew'� ,iU�������.���,`t�#�w� a 1. e,�Ii'��
��y'■I■,,tit1 ��� � I �1��+•��1IIIItIP ��WZ.L� '�4 — iF��CIY{�=1� ��i',� r'.,
Milli,
���. ���.�.■„��. ��2Y ,.�i.�,Ml�g ^=�e�a •Y✓t11//l � ���1� s? ,,t� ..�::"'�_
r►`•-'+rill ► ' . (}'r:l`j. "t` '�°! t �,( tlUnE� ��
wdt�tui-r •a
t.I � �.��� j �� a FFIII �•to\/If� �_
�'`'�il_. =*Y-`Y,v 1�..��J� °d�� tt-�-®:°(,r;C� ,���� �-• :�lui ��/afii�([ /' �I
.■—amain
,r�i�t 1�l► ���i=��'l.fl �Cts�e.t�ffik��6 n � Y��' ,/�.•I's
Ih�y, ■�frf� ����,ri `�-rla ��t ..try , - 1=1 IM
I•._�1 �......_ ♦dII.' tEtf�•11.�vtr • .'F.['� • ..fib 3'uipft °� a , �f.-r t ►,�E/ ♦ tlrtlFi: F�,
1 KL11r 1 6•� t■.ry �J� y'�fir. ,al me...r.t r®� a' ,
`i.��r� . re e.e•tilutrFrrlr ad��� r� 1F :�r1I (��r.il{ I�jIFr'
``• •�■ .� wr�im� Flu tIl a,es,l,rrr(i I►a, = (iL1�
gy�eL rL.nlu:t m k;r p viit�`i: `"'
._:...- ore F nr.cc-a ■ r-j r
�� '� IJ.. �F r�l F.1 CIA� ,, iru[i=i.itr����~.�+
W`r CFIt`Y:::�::; LtrH
,.i+.'�Ir. \ { ■tIr(:-. rar■u.ICil�` i � .g � �. .'�
Fir` (tHity��t+tr►.::flic.���.�.�r'-•�� j ► `r
1 ::r, •ai(.I ernnurCw
� �` tF1,h�1-° �. -F �•LEA E F/. u
�h
!�t
�'! 1 �Ir►n\�:ilft!,rn•Er��r�-r1ta'^ � ■� .i � � � 1 �+'�` -:rll
r��'�'� ���'•''.� �ttr�{I:'ti`Eiit�\���E�i '���iy �I <�� k��j��II tr,;� ,�� ([�
Ai �y -v7 -•�4 ern , 1. ~.. 1PF[f/ t
' (,�1•{'JWi�' �.♦iJ\Gl�u��iirl 'fir _ rt l - �' ♦-�.�
rr! ItHW nt;p_.y♦.`i.rr♦1��� 3da$�
r'Fr X111►f�1 HH ..��/_ t. fI(4Be`s '` ��/�►�� ���r
r•°°-�••-+��� tee_-� � dl�•�iF;��.. '��•-+-wv
��►� + �t �v�. r„ Ilrr:�tt rte t � r�r'��.
!• ��, _ ���I.. .�►rt'i■ .
tug si b, e•.. F
E ®® [((�{j�[��p-5�g��ggg�g
_.._._\�� - e irr �}FI �• ,�3t! �i [tFr cxer lBlEfFHElI91H {�QZ+• yy\ ��
`.��. 1 ��I�rll, r�q'` � � .a•• p,', t. 1'.-, dlt"m,,u{11���rl ill tit�t[I�1�' gPn: .j i9'tr* '00 /
,�'� � �4rr' i•;•i�ii5+" a.�m rim r
i �mn�t♦e�� �� - '�r ��W�v� x�t+T� � t® .� r�l.t;,.
....e ry i.- -v,c�.: .i $,"yF-trxt Py Hrtl �I�•--�� ,
%� �� •' fe;� I . 1 c f t'�4ttG .• �`tsB t6' id' ,'•.`' ..•'�•,'♦tR. •C+ I�1��
pia Hf t t[ �■mot ♦��((Ilin I�� l
n � 'Hr�P•♦r .' . a rszkl( 1 .4z�te tr..:r► .-; «t■ ...-.,�Li.•-
r 1° .'�
All L6 \ ��• � Ii�' S' SE.,.•__^�...��` � .�trtl-.t=�/IIIYBI"••�C'+���rt}
F—f a..-. cu"=���.�1 ♦'.- 1lI• r1[► •'
,IE:.W�C :rirj ,Wuut _ l+,f (
�� [t a IEFIttbr ^rte ,([ c3 = C♦._..,ren [ lfM��^;
l/ .,.w � aEP Ftf4•.- ,..Er.�h 3�:PH ..-r.i.: �� -�= _`�� l,r[I
Fit
�•
'= aa.v-.. °cc � .rap - ��'tf �IHIB� L r... .. � ..1�:�1��(/1� ,��ti ���
�I 1 ♦ ni��►■"._ = �:� fit, r j t J
ate i\� ,. ..__\+ �i
Mf1..171��� .i_�_�...1:.. ...r,...... ••-r.-- ��Ir�� _
R i a �+� ,. <,-g _ r_
F�frttrlr .�iat ` _ ���=�1 n==_
_/�, '` 9'r �f a ®�.li...F rliEt"FL1s•) i�tr� ` !� �� W111Etl1?FIEir 1��� a�•� t! � 11 RNA
.t• _r-��°' ��i"1.15'. �6 ��;��'.`" !s.�ior�,S ,/►.rLil C..t.tF� _�-;;�•'���►�i ri r_��c L�{.. • -•�_!
r't=. [- r' � '1 +I r � .,r■• t a.� t��la�- � I'1fG�`"•L'►. ir'►� 111"' �I
�■. - 1 '% ei.G' r ant s;.�7 �i _1\��, H `yr .k -r.,,., I„/ t;.,.
z 1 � \■ @. � .r a e � ♦ C I,s- � �' ir■t■-t�....����t�� fI , �/ ��"�'r�:�tl•[[V.
I,lrU�i & �I `
..�.� Via._�. • •�:�6 �' � _;,/ �:tttt:G:�.�i�l� k.��, .—_ jru `:^ ,�-rF�/` �ElrFttSlll�� l.t�•11 tIF(u
*�fgj.v=. °m.� ° '+I t�Fnn.y L. tI ••i fJii �.tJ 't. • i , ���! 1�1 u, Cai •
rr•g3 .JIJ ,r t�' ♦•unu'(� , rt+�l1 ^E r f[ IlllfttEfiF1..�J1 ')�E l
G I�®�. Ms" 1■�i■� 1,.� Ynt.Y HAS! �."�'il fR /�Yrf 1 - ��r�a�✓ I •ih�• �1!•C
°sf�.rt'�a 7 f r'"'t'+_h .u.r�E,� �r� ,Y y/11 :�;-�f�1111 1111111 iHER r(
s',se�. fie, t-.✓ '!°c-. Itli:aP 't�l�v`�tt�4'��<\ t.. l ` 1'
r �\
P11111,11
a •ari= .+ �` la+•i� ,l�r/i tis/ t
. 11'ILLi-�� WHr■ii■rL�••• ti.. ti r / t. / Sf /
�� Wr.�.•�C.`''.+w F■e�. t ,1y��.-►� /, -�..•I � 1���„ �i: .�
..... � _.. g6 dp'+i�°S�� - ...•If�A\ .wain►►FiCi►� „�'a ''"-�',-_�' rot<//rr�<< I..."��► 7�\.++1`,"'. �l�!�
.- I. 'c -- ..�``s�a��"ll�sp6`�e?,� i��1 f i ,` � 1 •u � w I cS.. 9r ���� t /r h pnk,,. �r1
,� � / f��f��,r��s�t'".. .r•� t 1�1���� �....p� ur t��\ ,., � 7'�►�r� �U'��,� ``�`�t�� ���•!y�•,.�
\ - �0� ,s�°%.i r' �,� .►,.. � �::��■.t��.:ttt r..�� zFt � �1't t t E,- ���1' ���'. FZe• �r-
�' .�iisp�.�..fa`•.r�����:irlritrr111(1I1�\\ �ttrt_..►rn�•..j`'ISti r�fC�``, ��7���������,�>_����.�«. .:�:< ft- wl�H-••
` � ai'+tRe# �.r��:,,��1+ �r t►. C.rl
r�♦ ♦ t t 1 tryj■ rrtnim [.aa[ u/, �vat'j �t �y1t�� riEltD t'.l
���� ��! �•+1► ntt.al,�tadd tt... . � i r�
p �_� t "': �r m t u�. IP✓ + i "' RN
�• \ � t�:Ir Ut .f,
V~� _ ,1;:..r/rrU �• _•rltc�.�ls;�� 1 s, F r....t....��,a..�olll,, '��. :�HF��-+��
� �7�rVia n r i/ CC*•!•• ! t,C t, rltltt6da,n r,I
r.+I..0 r� •I � � Ilt �Ftl t�tIItOC FlYn■tY Lttt • �� t
1►ttr�r E�i %� ►�:�.�`." L1'w61►r�. �li:�J•`.III/F1tlt..la,rrLO
{
,Ilh!IIl'Fiilt`�7.`
ILI
_a.a rut . +1 _e i`z•.+�1� '• Il[F►.e...w.i11rt MM.
111 ,1E
s-- „'„ ����;�' ��'nit�l�i�ra}r•J.tf',���
��G!� `''".. �• - �,.; ►, 1.1 , . r i��.��►.�• r� a Irk
� , � �► .Irtll `e;,,� 1 Etl'��';'1 r�tit \/\��E�,� F
�1pM
ON
U IN
�t..-.�LE�t► ►
111111 'rat I
Rivil-'����_ - .tn—•rt++:�tt fir' -+1......a1 ����ti=►�
��y rte'-�-.� �+��.IIr:F�.rl����nlifulr�,-��r►�
• ��i�a ��'��,� 1►�'at"'�yntt�l'I.r.!44k1 �r I��--i'•°��%�1,3�u:;.�.%'•rtrtr�
d► ��,/Z�l� � —ll� i ttatr;�y 4:t;�1� `► t1�R,�.� •�-��+��4',�' I
�" r/(�/•_as � � ��,{,I !-�. .�"-'�71.7 �Ilalt� �r� w�"�."_ .1
J C ��r t<<atMlil Ialtc_-• � � 'i `���� �'
-tapr
AM
,`'!.��t�[fil�l, .�z,:,_rir!!� ���►�,° .lrff ne•1 VF��L:. -.�t�r �l�r� ����
EXHIBIT "B"
Property Description
LEGAL PROPERTY DESCRIPTION
Being a tract of land situated in the John D. Hudson Survey, Abstract No. 741 and the William Hudson
Survey, Abstract No. 738 in the City of Fort Worth, Tarrant County, Texas and being a portion of
Block 4, Carter Industrial Park, per plat as recorded in Volume 388-31, Page 52 of the Deed Records
of Tarrant County, Texas and being a portion of the third tract as deeded to Carter Foundation
Production Company (aka Mereken Land &Production Company) per documents recorded in Volume
3587, Page 319 and Volume 3595, Page 24 of said Deed Records of Tarrant County, Texas, said tract
being more particularly described by metes and bounds as follows:
BEGINNING at a found V2 inch iron rod on the West R.O.W. line of Will Rogers Boulevard (a 110
foot wide R.O.W. per said plat) being or intended to be the Southeast comer of a tract deeded to Ivy
Corporation per document recorded in Volume 7665, Page 584 of said Deed Records, from said found
V2 inch iron rod a found 5/8 inch capped iron rod (Carter & Burgess) being or intended to be the
Northeast comer of said Ivy tract bears North 00 degrees 15 minutes 30 seconds West, a distance of
592.93 feet;
THENCE South 00 degrees 15 minutes 30 seconds East (Reference Bearing), along said West R.O.W.
line of Will Rogers Boulevard, a distance of 2022.52 feet to a set 5/8 inch capped iron rod (BBB INC)
being the Northeast comer of a tract deeded to Missouri Pacific Railroad Company per document
recorded in Volume 9941, Page 1080 of said Deed Records, from said set 5/8 inch capped iron rod
(BHB INC) a found 5/8 inch capped iron road (Carter & Burgess) bears South 00 degrees 15 minutes
30 seconds East, a distance of 50.00 feet of which is being or intended to be the Northeast comer of a
tract deeded to Mereken Land &Production Company per document recorded in Volume 12575, Page
2311 of said Deed Records;
THENCE South 89 degrees 45 minutes 00 seconds West, leaving said West R.O.W. line of Will
Rogers Boulevard and along the North line of said Missouri Pacific Railroad Company tract, a distance
of 624.22 feet to a set 5/8 inch capped iron rod (BBB INC), said set 5/8 inch capped iron rod (BHB
INC) also being the beginning of a curve to the right whose chord bears North 48 degrees 04 minutes
00 seconds West, a distance of 736.90 feet and having a radius of 548.69 feet;
THENCE Northwesterly, along said curve to the right along the Northerly line of said Missouri Pacific
Railroad Company tract,through a central angle of 84 degrees 22 minutes 01 seconds, an arc length of
807.94 feet to a set 5/8 inch capped iron rod(BBB INC) for the end of said curve;
THENCE North 05 degrees 52 minutes 59 seconds West, along the Easterly line of said Missouri
Pacific Railroad Company tract, a distance of 249.38 feet to a set 5/8 inch capped iron rod (BBB INC)
on the West line of said Block 4;
THENCE North 00 degrees 09 minutes 30 seconds West, along said West line of Block 4, a distance of
1279.51 feet to a found 5/8 inch iron rod being or intended to be the Southwest comer of a tract deeded
to Miller Brewing Company per document recorded in Volume 6822, Page 1602 of said Deed Records;
THENCE North 89 degrees 45 minutes 00 seconds East, along the South line of said Miller Brewing
Company tract, passing a found V2 inch iron rod at 428.70 feet and continuing along the South line of
said Ivy tract for a total distance of 1192.40 feet to the POINT OF BEGINNING and containing
2,336,380 square feet or 53.64 Gross acres of land of which 90,846 square feet or 2.09 acres lies within
a drainage area located along the southerly portion of said described tract between the 30 foot building
setback line and the top of bank as located in the field in the month of May, 1997 and the area of the
Chevron Pipeline Company Right of Way Easement lying Easterly of a 30 foot building setback line
being 8,573 square feet or 0.20 acre,leaving a net area of 2,236,961 square feet or 51.35 acres of land,
more or less.
EXHIBIT «C9
Tax Abatement Application
City of Fort
Tax Abatement
May 1996
' 4„d44411t1n�
po4�oRr�a�a
° o
0°000.°.0°°° d
aa�QARU44 44.0
Office of Economic Development
City Manager's Office
Fort Worth,Texas 76102
(817) 871-6103
City of Fort Worth
APPLICATION FOR
COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL TAX ABATEMENT
1. Applicant Information:
Name Ben E. Keith L Company
v
Address 601 E. 7th Street
City, State Zip Code Fort Worth Texas_ 76102
Telephone _817 ) 877 — 5700 ext.
Fax 81 338 — — 1701 ext.
Internet E-mail Address (if available): rQCBEKI Q AIRMAIL.NET
Contact Person (include title/position) Mel Cockrell, Chief Financial-D-Ui car
—
Name of property owner Ben E. Keith Company
2. Property Description
Attach legal description or surveyor's metes & bounds description.
3. Current Appraised Value of Property
Attach latest copy of property tax statement from the County Appraisal District.
4. Attach a brief description of the project including: services provided or products
manufactured, major customers and locations, etc.
5. Project Description
A. New Facilities
1. Size 412,600 —sq.ft
2. Cost of construction $ 28.0 million
B. Site Development (parking, fencing, landscaping, etc.):
1. Type of work to be done Earthwork, Site Pre
Utilities, storm Sewer System Paving.._ Rail_9aUZ13ite_IMp.MMMMan±_S_
and Landscaping.
2. Projected costs $ 5-7 Millina-
C. Personal Property:
1. Value of;
a. Inventory $ 16,000,000 (Includes Personal Property)
b. Supplies $
2. Percent of inventory eligible for•freeport exemption (inventory exported from
Texas within 175 days) 0 —0/6
3. Value of equipment, machinery, furnishings, etc. $
6. Project Construction:
A. What percent of the construction costs (5A. & B. above) will you commit to spend with:
1. Fort Worth businesses? 75 %
2. Minority and Women owned Business Enterprises? 10 %
B. When will construction start? jul-y 1998 - end? June 1999
C. HOW many construction jobs will be created? Average of loo construction jobs for
14 months
D. What is the estimated payroll for these jobs? 7-6 Million
7. Employment
A. Is this project an expansion or modernization of an existing facility? If so, please
answer the following: FWF 217
1. How many persons are currently employed? 270 KCD 22
ADMIN 31
2. What percent of 1. above are:
a. Ft.Worth residents? 40 %
b. Inner City residents? 21 %
B. Please complete the following table.
�4
Project Start Fifth Year Tenth Year
New Jobs to
be Created 425
Less
Transfers* 270
Net
Jobs 155
% of Net Jobs to
be filled by Ft.
Worth Residents' minimum of 25%
% of Net Jobs to
be filled by Inner
City Residents minimum of 8%
If any employees will be transfering,please describe where they will be transfering from.
Must be at least 25%.
C. Attach a description of the jobs to be created (technician, engineer, machinist, etc.),
task(s) to be performed by each, and wage rate for each classification.
We expect a net increase of 155 job's, as follows:
I Administrative 64 Sales 26 Warehouse Operations 64 Transportation
D. Attach a brief description of the employee benefit packagb(s) offered (le. health
insurance, retirement, public transportation assistance, day care provisions, etc.)
including portion paid by employee and employer respectively.
8. Regarding supply and service expenses (le. landscaping, office or manufacturing
supplies, janitorial services, etc.):
A. What is the annual amount of non-sole source supply and service expenses?
$ 450,000 Fo
B. What percentage of 8A.will be committed to Fort Worth businesses?
C. What percentage of 8A. will be'committed to Minority and Women Owned
Businesses?
9. Is the property appropriately zoned for this project?
10. Is the property platted? If yes, will replatting be necessary?
O
11. Attach a description of any environmental Impacts Aassociated with this project.
40APE
12. Attach a description of any direct benefits to the City of (Fort Worth as a result of
this project (le. sales tax, inventory tax, development fees, etc.)
13. Do you Intend to pursue abatement of:
County taxes? 9 Yes 0 No
School taxes? 0 Yes No
14. What level of abatement do you request: Years? 10 Percentage? see item 15
15. On an attachment, explain why tax abatement Is necessary for the success of
this project. Include a business pro forma or other documentation to substanti-
ate your request.
On behalf of the applicant, I certify the information contained in this application (including all
attachments) to be true and correct. I further certify that, on behalf of the applicant, I have
read the "Policy Statement:Tax Abatement For Qualified Development Projects" and agree
to comply with the guidelines and criteria stated therein.
chief F nanci,1J__01Lizar---
Name Title
May 12, 1998
Date
3
EMIT -Related to Item 7. C.
7., C. Attach a description of the jobs to be created(technician, engineer, machinist, etc.),
task(s) to be performed by each, and wage rate for each classification.
We expect a net increase of 155 jobs as follows:
Administrative 1
Sales 64
Warehouse Operations 26
Transportation 64
AAmftd&tmft . Addition of 1 person
This job'will be a general clerical position.
Salary range: $8.50 - $11.65 per hour..
Description: Compiles data and operates typewriter or computer in performance of routine
-clerical duties to maintain business I records and reports. Duties/tasks may include the
following: _
® Types reports, business correspondence, application forms, shipping tickets, and other
material.
® Reads instructions accompanying material, or follows verbal instructions Prom
supervisor or person requesting document, to determine format desired, number of
copies needed, priority, and other requirements.
a Types and revises material such as correspondence, reports, statistical tables,
addresses, and forms, from rough draft, corrected copy, recorded voice dictation, or
previous version displayed on screen.
e Files records and reports, posts information to records, sorts and distributes mail,
answers telephone, and performs similar duties.
• May operate duplicating machine to reproduce copy.
• May compute amounts, using adding or calculating machine.
• May type on or from specialized forms.
- Addition of 64 persons
These jobs will be primarily District Sales Representatives.
Salary range: $1000 - $3500 semi-monthly. Pay types vary including straight
commission,base plus commission, or salaried.
Description: Responsible for the sale of food products and/or services. Duties/tasks may
include the following:
• Direct one-to-one communication with customer,
• Field promotion work and developing new accounts,
• Demonstrates products or services and provides assistance in the best application of
product or services.
• Answers all questions concerning a product.or service, with appropriate referrals
where required.
• Closes transactions and takes orders,
• Estimates time and sales expenses expected and submits to management.
• Analyzes records'of present and past sales, trends and costs, estimated and realized
revenue, administrative commitments, and obligations incurred,
• Interprets accounts, trends, and records to management.
• Sells to new and present clients.
• Contacts prospects and explains features and merits of products or services offered,
utilizing persuasive sales techniques.
• May calculate and quote prices,
Warehause ®gerations - Addition of 26 persons
These positions will be primarily warehouse workers.
Salary range: $5.10 to $10,55 per hour,
Description: Performs any combination of the following tasks to receive, store, and
distribute material, tools, equipment, and products within warehouse.
• Reads production schedule, customer order, work order, shipping order, or
requisition to determine items to be moved, gathered, or distributed.
• Conveys materials and items from receiving areas to storage or to other designated
areas by hand, handtruck, or electric handtruck.
• Sorts and places materials or items on racks, shelves, or in bins according to
predetermined sequence, such as size, type, style, color, or product code.
• Sorts and stores perishable goods in refrigerated rooms.
• Assembles customer orders from stock and places orders on pallcts or shelves, or
conveys orders to packing station or shipping department.
• Marks materials with identifying information, using stencil, or other marking device.
• Opens bales, crates, and other containers, using handtools.
• Records amounts of materials or items received or distributed.
• May use computer to enter records.
• May complete requisition forms to order supplies from other departments.
• May maintain inventory records.
• May be known according to specific duty performed such as Order Selector,
Receving Clerk, Shipping Clerk, etc.
TransparWan - Addition of 64 persons
These postions will be primarily route delivery drivers.
Salary range: $400 - $900 per week. Paid by the piece, mile and stop.
Description: Drives truck over established route to deliver and sell products, collects
money from customers, and makes change. Duties/tasks may include the following:
• Drives truck to deliver food items to customer's place of business.
• Collects money from customers, makes change, and records transactions on
customer receipt.
• Writes customer order and instructions,
• Records sales or deliveries information on daily sales or delivery record.
• Informs regular customers of new products or services,
• Limns to and resolves service complaints.
• May place stock on shelves or racks.
• May set up merchandise and sales promotion displays or issue sales promotion
materials to customers.
• May collect or pick up empty containers or rejected or unsold merchandise.
• May load truck.
• May issue or obtain customer signature on receipt for pickup or delivery.
• May clean inside of truck,
BEN. a KEITH COMPANY -
SUMMARY OF EMPLOYEE BENEFITS -- 1998
.::?!%,.:ur..,.,!•:�h:r.�..,.:.v,.,..:.v �� '•L.� '>i')NI.r!l! .\%N' '4'w ,:1 � f 'H rt:r.����.
M4v•,.,!n;,..•,,:..v�:w,�.c.;rn!rnt•�;:...:M:.y+,rT"f•�•\,t\i�,;o,.L1,..rA•w,Z"�'ti^w`•.'...F.'.i: ..)!o'O. ...ri;:�.�', .,p': "c!y,!:).., ��ry,'anrtu`:
'tt,0�•� 4! V L N�..St,•wC,y.•„{ MNZ• '~ :.. > N.C. •i.i!! 4 W l
Y. Hsi. ..�,.,�., .:+ .!P..KIi:VA ,{a�:w�`�`xM"�''„y..:%.°.iw c .Y> 1. $T�.'9 ,>.f `3, 't' 'i•),'„+t:e��''t't.�.`'3'•ti�1�.C'^'f ^.d: .
:t :.�4 .„y:,, �tSA: !�!�'!,p n",�¢.,..a. v,•$.;r.•`�'',»”,:JAi,. Xi,?i.^'�","' :;;:`;Ktw
Maximum -$1,000,000
Deductible -$200.00 per calendar year, Eligibility Period - 1 at of month following 60
FPerson (not more than $600 per days of employment
family). Plus $200.00 per hospital
confinement-will be waived if using Cost- $ 55.00/Month for employee only
a hospital in the PHCS Network $160.00/Month for employee w/spouse only
Co-Payment -60% by Ben E. Keith $130.00/Month for employee w/children only
Company and 50% by employee to $2,000. $170,00/Month for employee w/family
Plan pays 100° of eligible oherges thereafter,
Prescription Card Benefit Wages used for premiums are non-taxable
$10.00 Generic/$16,00 Brand narne
Bil"M �, .,A"Cn•.f. �h w,W;,a.A:r�3wA' �"��.�,2, � ..•v:c��!•+1^`D �A����?� �"•_'.\ t•:q.. ^4: � '�'e1^ "7 r„�. h,•,
\,.,y.w::a..:' .;, .:+-:, !':'w�.,, j"<;e:, JC't Q;i';;w.;. b ,t'w'+a. •�L'�`xP":>.�,,,:f, `�;,::
.:,.;. ...I•i. ,�. .:n,;::>`:`�.,%��a�1.•ar.+!A.ii���i�',3;5.r.��gir;..L'\ii::.i..t'�..!`•'YiYl9p�v•
Two voluntary Dental Plans are available at the employee's option:
DMO Plan with Provider network of Regular Dental Insurance Plan
Dentists
Cost- $ 4.70/Month for employee only Cost - $21.62/Month for employee only
$ 7.55/Month for employee + bne dependent $43,20/Month for employee + one dependent
$10.40/Month for employee +two or more $53.97/Month for employee + two or more
Wages used for premiums are non-taxable
'.�•:v,,:n.\.giY.�,M"v;'•,i. .\r.C.,.�•M1...n:nM!•!;.5n.»:t�:.
..'L. u:`r;::.\n:n;!!.,�;`'Zr,'\.;!:..+q.�..`�.,•,:.µi•r'.f+.q. 't!',i+•„y..",to o?.:,...,.q:!.\".:%y;r.
..ry.. ). ,,.:'fie'!•g!r.\. :•.'iw.v.,.e>r.'„!C!C•.,:vr.. �uyl+^+'{n.n "<ra;:c:w,vy!r}F:.. +�::« ,:3'; ':;ra: •:•:x+ rti v.a\v::!.,•n:.;;,y..t,,o.:\..,..
h:;..•i��+,'MYn>1,..n:n+(.,,�.. r':w.,•,'�tit''CT•`\... ...... : •,��•\:i�:C'?:Y\):!f Y,,Y•"S'v'�';?n•;�i,;r ,:.4:>S.u� "��:t%:�'\,L:�'1..,.,.1;I:).\ ei;/.::..:F':\i:i,:�.:N.!;rr!nwu
:.,'•r.,�+,:\,.,.:N•^.•.'t.^.:t!Nnrr�...I•.. /.u.k.\w 6,,,..Vn./;� C .�w^.•'\+!y\ r.wf!C:. I, .,t•.r..v v'::•':1
:.;�•'. ..\`. .' ,�.. �\. !l:• .;:T":fir^���t:V.���•;�::>';;r\
:r•�:!r .�v, :<rn,:!• •,:d:r' ,.X .t»r• :C:a�n ;"`{.,..k;�. ...�. .t..•.: ..:f:. ,
..tra,:. ""^L'`J;'>.. :{v w �t ..'�t:,.,,'�>: ."?�E.,..e:R.... i5i'i•
i•w;,�,, �,.pJrt'!.,:M, r.\"i..::;�;;`». Y�rC't`•:n:'n1:!+It. ./.�.;..;ni?i (.w:r: ..V;:..!,�..;.,\::�:::y��.,!:;(:��+'i/:(,?,
' ",5^:,':••0• r.w'sC:T!,!h`ff'',. ....+,r•ni."?.'•r.,:xn .:. ....:::....
.:v,, :An. ::1.• .•d"• ,h:\ ^•\St'\`ii's..L'�,n?:k4„':,r.,!.�L»• ..;5°+'Ai” fji.:C:: ;ajil:i;�<;i;:a •ai�i '+yy�o
Coverage of$25,000 Eligibility period - 1 at of month following 60 days of
employment
Coverage is doubled should death Additional Life Insurance can be purchased as follows;
result from an accident
to th® employee $25,000• $ 6.50/Month
Cost- Nothing $50,000 - $13,00/Month
$75,000 - $19.50/Month
$100,000 - $26.00/Month
%f'%� v.\:r,�;•„'•',.i>'atr:. �:ti,i ! .'J'.;:n"'i%;3i .j.;:, :9.;: c.
a;....a �7wO.,. �?.•H
,�'tu:• n. Y`ti�''�/•��.`•�1'•• .,.,,...v:�•\°:4e.;.1., ':>r" :':i'i.: ;:;ti�:;tia� v.?. ::f;
fr,\.+\,;:. \'♦v.\f:.v,\J+. Pt n.�..� M �:"7•.. h.''1� ,:4/) �!V� "•':S%:' i:!,�'•r:U:•":�:HV^
.,v.. �:..r..� .i. �,y...,. .....rt,.'.•r!2,. �..c. w::v,:)w:. ,• ,•:a., trdi 4!fi••.
�:�'' r r>~. ,:.N.rig :. .�:•.. .,r. �,�•,,. ,'.>:
;.�,,•\,.. w4 M�,..><?!. ::n.. c.+Ta. 1... ,w�:., ..1. 'r`r,•nn;:. •.•!. ,r., ::;v::'ii(.,w.o:$:g:,,: .1.:!
.... .It..`:`...n ...,,.�Y•y'....:n M. ,...:...i...i w�,,��'�'�p!yy ..,.wi3:i i ..�. ...(,:,..:>{t^;..,.,\t n:n•.
..;7en•. ve"�......•7,v�°,•;�. .uy� "..v."�.. :YR7,d� i.;.e• .::a:,;•.r,:.:!j:�.•�.i�:�,:M .,,J.ros:....:..t..:;<T:C'5:�:;5'^;�.::�;`yrf:
,....... .\. .2 r.... ;,.A'•:%.,Y•w `,,,,,;i!•vKe,.,,Nom:^'`•... �(:. \:.,R�n:��..\iit}''•�t�r��i'v
2 Weeks after one (1) year service 3 Weeks after eight (S) years service
0,
�..»yt:o,;+•.:r.:.'!p:....gavg<p»�\[•st'!:'Y` :_.Y �r,;„,c»•>:.y;>::i'.., ._.g�•,:,y.._., v+n:•:'?,r.,: Sv:iw:n•.w .;.nr.•nq. '% •3S' '„Y{+t:. :a. .•,.M�,.,��jYr ..A..i7a>.':�f:r:!�f;r.•i;'77:v..::�'^rM.;�i
R.... ..ea`� sCl.:;. w,wt ....a.,,:n.�..... Y. ,<,. •h �,i,:r. '.t �3�?,:,, �.i"• •;T,• ..':F.�,. •;+• 3• �rJs'�''ifi ..,rw >.,.Y��•��•..�lr �;:.;�.
,4'tr,\�•(,•,,(•.:.!\`,,.�:.tJ'rl ri:..:),L:..t•f�.•y:;,r�v. .: �!. .�~•, v t. w�yr,�' w,{
I,:CVO"�•..:..w,�r;:'o',.::°,Yv:•. v,..:w w;?/�:�;. .,,i.vIr !3Y.•n:,......"},'.�� V34.Mi !+w.:w.',.✓ .w. :�,.':L. �I..4rI. ,,y,•{`�'f+r.h.7�•!t�vJC''rN'^•'v��i:�:,wY ••r�;:1�5
.t,\'S`ti :v� 'r'::�:.v:.,7,:.w'•.:in,,rw�T�r7.N:.,.i`,: >• •.,�15.... .v���,t,,.aCt,,i:/,, ./N'., n. %fit:q�'•t•J r::�,.,.t:r�ll,w,7,7.•,.w:r,�ri.`i4:tiv:'(.n„•:{i:i`Vr,�:lv::.�r::
117•„ Y..,�.vSYrv:Yw: •� M�lYy '•' .s..• .w.,r,:tW.w ...y,V Y+r•n•7�"•�'h"+''S;;r. !`I.' 3�{x....
Six (6) paid-holidays a year:
New Years Day Labor Day
Memorial Day Thanksgiving Day
Independence Day Christmas Day
�N
:^.._ .. ........:Rai•:....' ?a1;S" ,;?,>t:,e
.q..K...wv...\,..;:7:K•:t•vT,.,,,...7. .H?>:?fu.;•.••N,-.h,..�...Gf.Fi." [n. ': J' ,r,!•�' + ..,y;.w.•'r! :�'S i;4t'.i,'�a'i"'Yt,^3.•rC A, g S�•
•4f`.\�'I.ikk�'!7`�•'�',).�y.FY.�,�/'vvN,.•r%MHM':Y:o:v,�:'. ,�,•�v Ty!f .n
.:fv � .�»� /k ,�•'it"",��t�•ry,^�l�`n\'..�M�"W'•.{' r�r,�� 'cM�•p.l�:,(;•
,fir
�';'•! e•�+�',.°"w''��c3:1: ..'.'''.�.'''w�.i''y:`y�'i�^,l,r��°�• .. .:.i•- _ � r. �Jt'r:7
Financial aid for approved job-related educational courses
wffi a:<.: 'q:�:2$:.« r;Y.?if�i,;•h:,::ia' `;t'kR".r::h-� '�N' "•.6r7.'�T�'- •w.�i�'r.: :r"'!�:' 'r•••r.. .{ '�.^f(��.'°+N�t,)17c?»��.:t:h.�,'�>,•,;Y7',,r.,i�f`,+�Y2Gn
L"G�w�•'p'tt+,.a^'� k ,^!t ♦ �Y�+{. .. ,,. •, �' ��Y t rr w o e �, 3 .
• ^'.vJ�.uyy�, M'•M 4 »w•r\ v. / »:• -.'v. � �,; ,,tt•• �Y7+�rf!�.� {`v�1W,�,'±�lllY:�
Confidential counseling for employees and family members for
marital, financial, alcohol, drug related end other problems
;t.;.i:`J{•tj'n.:,'..5•e....,,/:./'t,t.,n:iyli..:Y.'I�Z{:...t.w...\,.ty w:/,L•.I.4S.�.A..w...,Y,.'p i�rlc.i.ei�...7 n fi{.5.s:+".f•.{,i:.zy:'(u N>,,�:7!r'r.t,y) •...Y.,.:�.'ti^�.;k(..J.0... ..:.. r
. r .
-1. t �w ,
')'� 'f.• •'r.��(!,>i�'•,• •...:yi .i•.`�..F°:ln.q..7Y.�w:�.wi`!wn"��7;�,'•:r t�-.:'YS.•`�t,,.'.4�,.rk:�..»`t'r•xi^,�i':�!d?G:<'.'l�,S'�j'�t'">''fi:"1:;'w::
1'
Lfi2.tC.,,
/
•
Cash incentives for safety, for applicable positions
.................,....•r:..................:.:..e:.va" ......,%.>.' »rwP}•H' �'•::�;......,•,;',e:r,.,.t. �� ���.:�. 4vw. w;1.µ i:WeF°, '�'�%:`R.'<:.^''.<R�r7li�:;•
.k;�;l:;....ro.r..o a....y..,..,�.....:. .Y^�% ..;ra,Sp.!.,t.�...•' '.6r.. ,....•min.... .o,. ."r." w:�oo• "Y.:' ,y..r .,:� a'°:`r.Y ..e... .t
..53•l..,iw:,P�`r'SC:,»Rnr.u4;:'r ,�":j:: ...h» '•er.,r'�:8n" ':.�`.Cf.t:. `�'1t''..'•.'�•'.�'':':' ti•! fn7••�X'!f';`•.�.'r.g ::�l::ix.
rr.•.,;..;;'::;.•rr... ;••.tc'rc;t t:a•:-:a\•>a .:':,::"•.�at.t r:' ;! v. �f ^' .,�,.+.y ce:i�' R :r.. •'.`• ,c,:n:v
+l;r{k:!±,:'t;,•t,.'.;:.L`:�.e..:•' or(.srry;•,•�,',' >%' .;r,. :F' 'r?i.�.' ..(:. ''t''34j„•;, "� ;(,.� rnY: ...
,., q�JJ:'k`� �k„< � .;,,��.'.�. � � -,,.'.�,3:1.';� `�. � n:%`i+"r,{;f. �: si•:3".�
;,t6\.;.;xtv.�'v;^•.. �<.ol""c~.:R,ta;:'�u:.••4 sL`� ,f,:� ,..,y,:,n
A piece to save, a place to borrow Payroll deduction makes it easy to save
Loans and shares insured
�':Ft �;K•:'.'�c.'�`<t':�tY"••'��..'•��s�°�''• 'i:i`' w.+ "x •.`:' s�' N'• at t:i''K`�k�`' ^`y'. ;i ,w .a� ' .N.,Iw.6c^,, .¢g�!'. '
;•r•..,.p :.;tF,r-
i'�'.�'•`•':,.uai^ '
Lump sum payment at retirement Amount at retirement depends on income
and number of years of service
Fully vested in seven (7) years - begin Waiting period to participate - 1 year
vesting in three (3) years at 20%
Death and disability benefits included Cost- Nothing to the employee
.e•. v¢w ��.ey pT''.'::Jity::1{2' in:f✓':::;;�f[i,�2Ci1i3 ,:fo:yvzw�::,i?f��:;•:+r
t... ,wgyaZ.w::<:« ^..%.�,..•>.••c:^ a'I17:' .'F ,,...: ..�.M... ..:$wi'''4'3:ayi>�.. ^;;�w'.;;;r;- ,,�..:gj�',:$+n. .w,. :':�\5:�::'�:1;' �':
. Y..r1ri,.»Y,'i•,.y:7,i,.v,wYw�W. ,.!tI,Y,�Na......, 'r'•T?•:?� ?fN>! t
rr.:+„7:•,.... 7 .�(+.. wr;.n .'wv. ,,,,.:. �...'�iS:,;,.s..r^..,.: 4 w'ji •r .,:'",�,, n,N ti` .-w;;7 �::t'�,`>1'r`,:Y <3' j,veya.
!. .:�!:•:z:w•.r•u:c,,,a;> ''tz�4wt:,.:air .Y .cans+.::' ..� iv;:w"'y>.,r.y; tya~...w:i�ay�Fi�' .t::,..'. .•+vr�•TV... e�y`•;
.��c..+.sy..,an.,.: /,,.ry;•:.:_K:��Nu'1.:���:'•°w'�j%•'?Li::a'%;tl�\�;7�* !: .::�'tc:' ,�..::.. ,�I!Sl"..y p:.,r...r;.... :,�:::•' .'!tY
.;:tea.",.'. .:;...1.r?�»i:.�...;c•,:.v..�:v�«;s.y,:.w..o-rcMrb a '.;1:'�',e.''n. :; :. '�Y.�""�....•w:� :�",L"c".".o'o`':. `.,s�.'w...,Y>~:C,L�.:•:it:M:•.v
..a•,`::.+ ,.. :A••,.:Yr:17...w`-: rVew]:�':L, •{`.:.w `•...N�': •.v:t+�:v w:+. •:.ww� t�.^ ^•x•�:•..
Pays monthly income for fife at age Death and disability benefits included
65 or older. May retire at age 50,
with ten years of service, at a reduced Waiting period to participate - 1 year
monthly Income.
Fully vested in five (5) years Cost - Nothing to the employee
F-f rective 1/1/88
This benefit summery provides a brier outline of the Ben E. Keith Benern Program. it is not a contract. Please refer to
your Employee Handbook or other specific brochures which explain these benefits in greater detail.
15. Ben E. Keith Company is consolidating its Dallas and Fort Worth distribution
warehouses into one larger more efficient facility. We have outgrown the two
present warehouses and we need a more modern and efficient structure with an
automated warehouse management system and higher density racking.
The new facility will service a large geographical area from Shreveport, Louisiana
south to Houston, from Houston west to Big Bend Country, from Big Bend north
to Abilene, from Abilene east to North and East Texas, including Fort Worth and
Dallas.
The decision has been made to build either in Dallas or Fort Worth. Even though
we cover a vast territory, our sales volume comes primarily from the metroplex.
Although the mid-cities were considered,they have several drawbacks and we
have all but eliminated them at this time.
As between Dallas and Fort Worth,there are many important factors, but the most
critical is cost. Foodservice distribution is a low margin business. Our Profit
Before Tax in 1997 was only 2.6% of sales and in 1996 it was just 1.9%.
Whichever City we can operate in most economically will be where we locate. A
tax abatement could very easily make the difference.
We respectfully ask the City Council to consider a tax abatement for the
following reasons:
1. We currently employ 270 people in Fort Worth. These jobs and the
economic value they bring to Fort Worth will be lost if we move to Dallas.
2. The new facility will employ 425 people. Rather than losing 270 jobs,
Fort Worth has the opportunity of gaining an additional 155 jobs and the
economic value that would bring.
3. We already have enough land at our Dallas facility on which to build the
consolidated warehouse. We also own vacant land in Fort Worth at Carter
Industrial Park. One alternative would be to sell the Carter Property and
use this money to help finance the construction in Dallas. The Carter
Property is worth $ 3,000,000.
4. To expand our present Dallas facility to 412,600 sq. ft. would cost an
estimated $ 20 million or$ 8 million less than building at a new site in
Fort Worth.
5. The City of Fort Worth will retain the property tax revenue it already gets
from our current warehouse at 600 E. 9P Street, which was $ 100,342 in
1997.
6. Additional personal property taxes will be generated at the new facility
due to increased inventory levels. In 1997 we paid $ 309,372 on personal
property of$ 10.5 million. We expect inventories to increase over$ 2.0
million.
7. During construction there will be an average of 100 new construction jobs
created over a 14 month period. The estimated payroll for these jobs is
$ 7.6 million.
8. All total we will be investing over$37 million mostly in the Fort Worth
economy. We will instruct our engineering firm to use minority and
women owned businesses wherever possible.
9. Ben E. Keith is a federal contractor and follows an affirmative action
program to maintain diversity in the workforce.
10. Ben E. Keith company has been a leading supporter of Fort Worth over
the years. We have sponsored many events and contributed to many other
City supported endeavors such as our gift of$ 250,000 to the Bass
Performance Hall.
Ben E. Keith Company has its roots in Fort Worth dating back to 1906. We believe we
have been a good corporate citizen and we are not asking for special treatment. We
simply request the same consideration given other companies. In order for us to remain
here we need financial help from the City in the form of a tax abatement as shown below.
Ben E. Keith is requesting a graduated ten-year tax abatement on real property that could
reach 75%.
The abatement is structured as follows:
Base abatement of 30%for base commitments:
FW resident employees 108 (if not reached reduce by 5%)
IC resident employees 54 (if not reached reduce by 10%)
FW supply & service contracts 50% (if not reached reduce by 5%)
M/WBE supply and service contracts 10% (if not reached reduce by 10%)
Additional tax abatement increment can be achieved on any given year through the
increased employment of Fort Worth and Inner City residents. The ability to increase the
abatement above the 30%base will be as follows:
• For each additional FW resident above the 108 base commitment of FW employees,
the company will obtain one additional percentage point of tax abatement with a cap
of 25 additional percentage points for Fort Worth resident hiring.
- 1 FW resident over 108 = 1%increase in abatement over base (25% cap)
• For each additional IC resident above the 54 base commitment of IC employees, the
company will obtain one additional percentage point of tax abatement.
- 1 FW resident over 54 = 1% increase in abatement over base
We respectfully ask the City of Fort Worth for this tax abatement so we can continue the
longtime partnership we have all enjoyed in the past. Thank you very much.
Ben E. Keith Company:
Tax Abatement Application Summary
Background/Project Description
Ben E. Keith Company is a food service and beer distributor that has been in Fort Worth
since 1906. The company is in the process of consolidating its Dallas and Fort Worth
distribution warehouses into one larger more efficient facility. The current location of the
Fort Worth distribution center is in downtown on East 9"' Street.
Ben E. Keith Company intends to build a 412,000-sq. ft. facility with an estimated cost of
construction of$28 million. Total investment at the chosen Fort Worth location at Carter
Industrial Park would exceed $40 million. The new project would keep the current 270
full time employees in Fort Worth and would add 155 full time employees.
Currently, Ben E. Keith pays over $120,000 in taxes to the City of Fort Worth annually.
The estimated taxes at the new facility, including real and personal property and
inventory, at the current tax rate would exceed $400,000 annually. The tax abatement
request for this project is a ten-year tax abatement on real property that would be based
on performance in commitment areas with a cap of 75%. Details of the project are as
follows:
Investment:
® Real Property: $28,000,000
® Personal Property & Inventory: $16,000,000
Fort Worth Based Contractors/Subcontractors:
Construction ($28,000,000): 75% - $21,000,000
Supply & Services ($450,000): 50% - $225,000
MBE/WBE Commitments:
Construction ($28,000,000): 10% - $ 2,800,000
Supply & Services ($450,000): 10% - $45,000
Employment: Commitment
Net New Jobs:
Total 425
Transfers 270
Total new f55
Ft. Worth 108
Inner City 54
Requested gested Abatement:
Ben E. Keith is requesting a graduated ten-year tax abatement on real property that could
reach 75%.
The abatement is structured as follows:
Base abatement of 30% for base commitments:
FW resident employees 108 (if not reached reduce by 5%)
IC resident employees 54 (if not reached reduce by 10%)
FW supply & service contracts 50% (if not reached reduce by 5%)
M/WBE supply and service contracts 10% (if not reached reduce by 10%)
Additional tax abatement increment can be achieved on any given year through the
increased employment of Fort Worth and Inner City residents. The ability to increase the
abatement above the 30% base will be as follows:
• For each additional FW resident above the 108 base commitment of FW
employees, the company will obtain one additional percentage point of tax
abatement with a cap of 25 additional percentage points for Fort Worth
resident hiring.
- 1 FW resident over 108 = 1% increase in abatement over base (25% cap)
• For each additional IC resident above the 54 base commitment of IC
employees, the company will obtain one additional percentage point of tax
abatement.
I FW resident over 54= 1% increase in abatement over base
The total tax abatement has a cap of 75%per annum.
Abatement Details Over Life of Abatement at highest level (10 yrs. @ 75%):
ANNUAL
Taxes Abatement/ Freeport Net
Real Prop. Value: $275,000 ($153,870) $121,130
Pers. Prop & Inv.: $147,200 $ 0 $147,200
Total $422,200 ($153,870) $268,330
EX1IIBIT"All
LEGAL PROPERTY DESCRIPTION
Being a tract of land situated in the John D. Hudson Survey, Abstract No. 741 and the William Hudson
Survey, Abstract No. 738 in the City of Fort Worth, Tarrant County, Texas and being a portion of
Block 4, Carter Industrial Park, per plat as recorded in Volume 388-31, Page 52 of the Deed Records
of Tarrant County, Texas and being a portion of the third tract as deeded �to Carter Foundation
Production Company (aka Mereken Land &Production Company) per documents recorded in Volume
3587, Page 319 and Volume 3595, Page 24 of said Deed Records of Tarrant County, Texas, said tract
being more particularly described by metes and bounds as follows:
BEGINNING at a found 1/z inch iron rod on the West R.O.W. line of Will Rogers Boulevard (a 110
foot wide R.O.W. per said plat) being or intended to be the Southeast comer of a tract deeded to Ivy
Corporation per document recorded in Volume 7665, Page 584 of said deed Records, from said found
V2 inch iron rod a found 5/8 inch capped-iron rod (Carter & Burgess) being or intended to be the
Northeast comer of said Ivy tract bears North 00 degrees 15 minutes 30 seconds West, a distance of
592.93 feet;
THENCE South 00 degrees•15 minutes 30 seconds East (Reference Bearing), along said West R.O.W.
line of Will Rogers Boulevard, a distance of 2022.52 feet to a set 5/8 inch capped iron rod (BBB INC)
being the Northeast comer of a tract deeded to Missouri Pacific Railroad Company per document
recorded in Volume 9941, Page 1080 of said Deed Records, from said set 5/8 inch capped iron rod
(BHB INC) a found 5/8 inch capped iron road (Carter & Burgess) bears South 00 degrees 15 minutes
30 seconds East, a distance of 50.00 feet of which is being or intended to be the Northeast comer of a
tract deeded to Mereken Land &Production Company per document recorded in Volume 12575, Page
2311 of said Deed Records;
THENCE South 89 degrees 45 minutes 00 seconds West, leaving said West R.O.W. line of Will
Rogers Boulevard and along the North line of said Missouri Pacific Railroad Company tract, a distance
of 624.22 feet to a set 5/8 inch capped iron rod (BBB INC), said set 5/8 inch capped iron road (BHB
INC) also being the beginning of a curve to the right whose chord bears North 48 degrees 04 minutes
00 seconds West, a distance of 736.90 feet and having a radius of 548.69 feet;
THENCE Northwesterly, along said curve to the right along the Northerly line of said Missouri Pacific
Railroad Company tract,through a central angle of 84 degrees 22 minutes 01 seconds, an arc length of
807.94 feet to a set 5/8 inch capped iron rod (BBB INC) for the end of said curve;
THENCE North 05 degrees 52 minutes 59 seconds West, along the Easterly line of said Missouri
Pacific Railroad Company tract, a distance of 249.38 feet to a set 5/8 inch capped iron rod (BBB INC)
on the West line of said Block 4;
THENCE North 00 degrees 09 minutes 30 seconds West, along said West line of Block 4, a distance of
1279.51 feet to a found 5/8 inch iron rod being or intended to be the Southwest comer of a tract deeded
to Miller Brewing Company per document recorded in Volume 6822,Page 1602 of said Deed Records;
THENCE North 89 degrees 45 minutes 00 seconds East, along the South line of said Miller Brewing
Company tract, passing a found Y2 inch iron rod at 428.70 feet and continuing along the South line of
said Ivy tract for a total distance of 1192.40 feet to the POINT OF BEGINNING and containing
2,336,380 square feet or 53.64 Gross acres of land of which 90,846 square feet or 2.09 acres lies within
a drainage area located along the southerly portion of said described tract between the 30 foot building
setback line and the top of bank as located in the field in the month of May, 1997 and the area of the
Chevron Pipeline Company Right of Way Easement lying Easterly of a 30 foot building setback line
being 8,573 square feet or 0.20 acre, leaving a net area of 2,236,961 square feet or 51.35 acres of land,
more or less.
City of Fort orth, Texas
4basor and council con1munlentlao"
DATE REFERENCE NUMBER LOG NAME PAGE
7/7/98 �®� ��6 02KEITH 1 of 3
SUBJECT MAKE FINDING&CONCERNING A PROPOSED'TAX ABATEMENT AGREEMENT WITH
THE BEN E. KEITH COMPANY AND AUTHORIZE EXECUTION OF THE AGREEMENT
RECOMMENDATION:
It is recommended that the City Council:
1. Find that the improvements contained within the*attached agreement are feasible and practical
and would be a benefit to the land and to the City after the expiration of the tax abatement
agreement; and
2. Find that written notice of the City's intent to enter into the attached Tax Abatement Agreement
and copies of the agreement were delivered to all affected taxing units in accordance with state
law;;and
3. Find that the terms and conditions of the Agreement and the property subject to the Agreement
meet the criteria of the City's Policy Statement: Tax Abatement for Qualifying Development
Projects (the "Tax Abatement Policy") as approved by M&C G-12143 (Resolution No. 2379); and
4. Authorize the City Manager to enter into the attached Tax Abatement Agreement with the Ben E.
Keith Company in accordance with the Tax Abatement Policy.
DISCUSSION:
The property subject to abatement is located in the Carter Industrial Park in south Fort Worth. The City
Council has designated this property as Tax Abatement Reinvestment Zone Number 30. This
reinvestment zone is located in Council District 8.
Project.
Ben E. Keith Company is a food service and beer distributor that has been in Fort Worth since 1906.
The company is in the process of consolidating its Dallas and Fort Worth food distribution warehouses
into one larger more efficient facility. The current location of the Fort Worth distribution center is in
downtown on East 9th Street. At the Carter Park location, Ben E. Keith Company intends to build a
412,000-square foot facility with a $28 million estimated cost of construction. Total investment will
exceed $40 million.
Employment.
The new distribution center will employ 425 people at the facility. The Ben E. Keith Company has
committed to maintain a minimum of 108 Fort Worth residents as employees for a 30% base tax
abatement amount. A further commitment to maintain 54 inner city residents as employees has been
made to obtain the 30% base tax abatement amount.
City of Foil Woilh, Texas
4Vagor and Councit Communication
DATE 7/7/98 REFERENCE NUMBER C-1 6886 1 11 NAME 02KEITH PAGE
2 of 3
SUBJECT MAKE FINDINGS CONCERNING A PROPOSED TAX ABATEMENT AGREEMENT WITH
THE BEN E. KEITH COMPANY AND AUTHORIZE EXECUTION OF THE AGREEMENT
Utilization of Fort Worth Businesses:
The company has committed 75% of the total of $28 million in construction to Fort Worth construction
contractors and/or subcontractors. Additionally, of the $450,000 projected to be spent on supplies and
services annually, a commitment to spend 50% with Fort Worth based service and supply contractors
and/or sub-contractors has been made.
Utilization of it YWBE Businesses:
Ben E. Keith Company has committed 10% of the total of $28 million in construction to Minority and
Women Business Enterprises (M/WBE) construction contractors and/or subcontractors. Additionally, of
the $450,000 projected to be spent on supplies and services annually, a commitment to spend 10%
with M/WBE service and supply contractors and/or sub-contractors has been made.
Abatement Terms:
The abatement level in the agreement is based on the company meeting base commitments for a bass,
level of abatement with the ability to grow the abatement by performing at higher levels in 4.1he
employment commitments. The abatement will apply only to the increased value of the real propefty.
The annual abatement level will be based on the following schedule for the agreed 10-year term.
Base abatement of 30% for base commitments of:
Fort Worth resident employees 108 (if not reached reduce base by
Inner city resident employees 54 (if not reached reduce base by
Fort Worth suppliers and service contracts 50% (if not reached reduce base by
M/WBE suppliers and service contracts 10% (if not reached reduce base by 0%"
Additional tax abatement increment can be achieved on any given year through increased er-'r,P'Vpme-nt
of Fort Worth and inner city residents. For each additional Fort Worth resident above the 108
commitment of Fort Worth employees, the company will obtain one additional percentage 'p, mvk of tax
abatement with a cap of 25 additional percentage points for Fort Worth resident hiring, For sach
additional inner city resident above the 54 base commitment of inner city employees, the ��,Tqreny Will
obtain one additional percentage point of tax abatement.
The total tax abatement has a cap of 75% per annum.
If the maximum abatement (75%) is reached, the abated taxes are projected to be
At the 75% tax abatement level, the projected taxes paid to the City will be $268,331-i", anr,,'_;PA'y.
Currently, taxes paid to the City by the food distribution division of the Ben E. Keif2.-,-,
$127,714 annually.
City of Fort Worth, Texas
qV61yor and council COMM uni enti 01M
DATE 7/7/98 REFERENCE NUMBER C-1 6886 1 LOG NAME 02KEITH I PAGE 3 of 3
SUBJECT MAKE FINDINGS CONCERNING A PROPOSED TAX ABATEMENT AGREEMENT WITH
THE BEN E. KEITH COMPANY AND AUTHORIZE EXECUTION OF THE AGREEMENT
FISCAL INFORMATION/CERTIFICATION:
The Finance Director certifies that approval of this agreement will have no material effect on City funds.
MG:rn
Submitted for City Manager's FUND ACCOUNT CENTER AMOUNT CITY SECRETARY
Office by: (to) APPROVED
Mike Groomer 6140 CITY COUNCIL
Originating Department Head: JUL 7
Tom Higgins 6192 (from) v
(1-7
Additional Information Contact: City SscrsL-ary Of th6
City of—foot Vlorlh,'rexas
Jay Chapa 8003